HiDream E1 HiDream AI P-Image Edit PrunaAI

Settled by community votes across 4 shared challenges, with an AI judge weighing in on each.

HiDream E1

0.7 arena score

#33 of 32 in Image Editing

Skill signature · Image Editing

P-Image Edit

9.5 arena score

#29 of 32 in Image Editing

Vote tally

Where the votes landed

HiDream E1

win rate

Ties

P-Image Edit

win rate

Shared challenges 4

Challenge by challenge

The strongest take from each model on every shared challenge, with the AI judge's read.

Bald man challenge

Image Editing

Edit instruction

“Give the person a full, thick head of natural hair with realistic texture, density, and a natural hairline. Preserve facial features and lighting.”

HiDream E1

P-Image Edit

AI Judge Analysis

HiDream E1

+ Successfully added a large volume of hair as requested.
+ Maintained the overall pose and identity of the subject.

− Completely changed the background from a desert scrub to a simplified CGI-looking landscape.
− Produced a painterly/filtered texture on the face and jacket that destroys the original photographic quality.
− The hair looks like an unnatural wig with strange, uniform waves.

P-Image Edit

+ Excellent source preservation, keeping the background and clothing identical to the original.
+ Realistic integration of hair texture with the existing beard.
+ Maintains original image quality and lighting perfectly.

− The curly texture of the hair is slightly different from the straight texture of the beard.
− The height of the hair is a bit exaggerated.

Verdict: P-Image Edit is the clear winner because it successfully performed the edit while preserving 100% of the original image's background, lighting, and texture. HiDream E1 failed the prompt's preservation requirement by regenerating the entire image in a different style, resulting in a loss of photographic detail and a changed background.

Over-the-top cartoon caricature

Editing

Edit instruction

“Create a caricature of me and my job. Make it exaggerated and humorous, incorporating my profession as a tv show anchor and my love for dogs and hockey.”

Source

HiDream E1

P-Image Edit

AI Judge Analysis

HiDream E1

+ Features a clear caricature style with exaggerated facial proportions.
+ Successfully integrates hockey players, a dog, and a professional blazer

− The character's face loses much of the likeness of the original woman, looking significantly older and different.
− Hand and finger rendering is quite messy and distorted.

P-Image Edit

+ Excellent preservation of the subject's facial features and likeness in a caricature style.
+ Comprehensive integration of all prompt elements including TV mic, hockey rink background, and dogs.
+ Superior composition with a more natural 'on-set' feel.

− Text on the displays is nonsensical gibberish.
− The dog at the bottom right has a strange, over-designed red heart accessory that looks cluttered.

Verdict: P-Image Edit is the clear winner as it maintains an impressive likeness to the woman in the source image while transforming her into a caricature, whereas HiDream E1 creates a generic character that looks nothing like the original. P-Image Edit also does a much better job of storytelling, placing the character in a complete TV broadcast environment with better thematic details like the microphone and hockey arena.

Studio Ghibli Anime Style

Editing

Edit instruction

“Transform this photo into a Studio Ghibli–inspired illustration. Use soft pastel colors, hand-painted textures, gentle lighting, dreamy backgrounds, and a warm, nostalgic mood”

Source

HiDream E1

P-Image Edit

AI Judge Analysis

HiDream E1

+ Successfully replicates a simpler, late-90s anime style.
+ Captures the character positions and basic expressions well.

− Changed clothing colors significantly, losing the iconic red dress.
− The art style is more generic 'webcomic' than the specific hand-painted Ghibli aesthetic.
− Background is very abstract and lacks the requested dreamy detail.

P-Image Edit

+ Excellent preservation of original colors, including the iconic red dress and plaid shirt.
+ High-quality hand-painted textures that much more closely resemble Studio Ghibli's background art.
+ Perfectly captures the subtle facial expressions and complex lighting requested.

− The man's face leans slightly more towards a modern digital painting style than traditional anime.

Verdict: P-Image Edit is the clear winner as it masterfully balances the 'Studio Ghibli' aesthetic with perfect preservation of the original image's key elements, like the red dress and character likenesses. HiDream E1 fails to keep the source colors and provides a much simpler, flatter illustration style that lacks the requested hand-painted texture and dreamy background.

Golden Hour Stroll

Image Editing

Edit instruction

“Add dynamic motion to this photo: make hair blow in the wind, add leaves flying, energetic and lively feel.”

HiDream E1

P-Image Edit

AI Judge Analysis

HiDream E1

+ Excellent addition of wind-blown hair that maintains a natural flow
+ Leaves are large and clearly visible, matching the energetic prompt
+ Preserves the subject's face and the dog with high fidelity

− The red leaves look somewhat like generic clip-art and don't match the background foliage
− Slight saturation boost makes the image look less natural than the original

P-Image Edit

+ Small, yellow leaves integrate much better with the colors of the existing environment
+ The hair edit feels very dynamic and adds a symmetric sense of motion
+ Excellent preservation of the original image's lighting, skin tones, and texture

− Some leaves are extremely small and may be mistaken for digital artifacts at first glance

Verdict: Both models handled the edit instruction very well, but P-Image Edit is the winner due to its superior integration of the added elements. While HiDream E1 added large, stylized red leaves that clashing with the scene, P-Image Edit used smaller yellow leaves that felt realistic to the park setting. Additionally, P-Image Edit achieved a more convincing 'windy' effect on the hair while maintaining the original image's color grade and texture.