GPT Image 1 Mini OpenAI P-Image Edit PrunaAI

Settled by community votes across 1 shared challenge, with an AI judge weighing in on each.

GPT Image 1 Mini

25.3 arena score

#12 of 44 in Text-to-Image

Skill signature

Not enough comparable category data

The chart appears once both models have ratings across at least three shared arena categories.

P-Image Edit

0.2 arena score

#24 of 23 in Image Editing

Vote tally

Where the votes landed

GPT Image 1 Mini

100.0%

win rate

Ties

0.0%

P-Image Edit

0.0%

win rate

100.0% 0.0% ties 0.0%

Shared challenges 1

Challenge by challenge

The strongest take from each model on every shared challenge, with the AI judge's read.

Outfit Transfer Challenge

Editing

Edit instruction

“Use Image 1 as the base person. Dress them in the exact elaborate outfit from Image 2 (including all layers, accessories, jewelry, and shoes). Carefully adapt the clothing to the body shape and pose in Image 1 while maintaining realistic fabric behavior, correct proportions, and perfect lighting/shadow matching. Keep the person’s exact face, hair, and background completely unchanged.”

Source

GPT Image 1 Mini

P-Image Edit

100% wins 0% ties 0% wins

AI Judge Analysis

GPT Image 1 Mini

+ Excellent preservation of the subject's face, skin markings (vitiligo), and features from Image 1.
+ Accurately replicates the coat, scarf pattern, and watch from Image 2.
+ High visual quality with realistic lighting and shadows integrated into the original scene.

− Changes the hair style slightly (making him bald) instead of keeping it completely unchanged.
− The scarf pattern is simplified compared to the source.

P-Image Edit

+ Successfully includes the sunglasses and gold chain from Image 2.
+ Maintains the background of Image 1 well.

− Completely fails to preserve the person from Image 1, replacing him with the man from Image 2.
− The hand on the scarf has anatomical distortions.
− The lighting on the subject feels artificial and pasted-on compared to the background.

Verdict: GPT Image 1 Mini followed the complex instructions much better by keeping the unique facial features and skin condition of the person in Image 1 while applying the clothing from Image 2. P-Image Edit failed the primary directive of 'keeping the person's exact face' and instead simply pasted the man from the second image into the background of the first. GPT Image 1 Mini's result is a cohesive and realistic edit, despite a minor change to the subject's hair.