Qwen Image Edit 2511 Alibaba vs Wan 2.7 Alibaba

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent preservation of the man's facial features and clothing.
• + Realistic and high-quality interior detailing for the car.
• + Perfect scenery that accurately reflects the California coastline.

• − The car interior/dashboard design was changed from the source image's convertible style.
• − The man's scale relative to the car seems slightly cramped.

Wan 2.7

• + Successfully preserved the original car's exterior design and perspective perfectly.
• + Good composition showing the car moving along the road with motion blur.

• − The man's face and identity are completely lost and replaced with a distorted figure.
• − The person in the car is barely visible and does not represent the man from the source image.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Matches the background environment of Image 2.
• + Retains the man from Image 2 in the scene.

• − Fails completely to map the character from Image 2 onto the pose from Image 1.
• − Simply overlays the woman from Image 1 onto Image 2's background.
• − Creates a nonsensical composition with the woman floating in front of the man.

Wan 2.7

• + Perfectly maintains the pose and environment from Image 1.

• − Fails to perform the edit requested.
• − Completely ignores the character reference from Image 2.
• − Provides an output identical to the source Image 1.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Matches the specific clothing items from Image 2 (blue coat, plaid scarf, sunglasses).
• + Successfully integrates black dress shoes into the scene.

• − Completely failed to preserve the person from Image 1, replacing the face and skin characteristics with the person from Image 2.
• − Extensive cropping and movement of the subject changed the composition.

Wan 2.7

• + Perfectly preserved the original person's face, hair, and unique skin features from Image 1.
• + Excellent integration of the pose and body into the beach environment.

• − Hallucinated an entirely different outfit (gold embroidery, multiple necklaces) instead of the one in Image 2.
• − Ignored the specific clothing reference image.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent preservation of the original facial features and expression.
• + Matches the beard texture well with the new curly hair.
• + Strong adherence to the 'thick head of hair' instruction with believable lighting.

• − The hairline on the side near the ear looks a bit detached or floating.

Wan 2.7

• + Natural, realistic hair volume and style that fits the character's age.
• + Seamless integration of the hair with the original skin and forehead.
• + Perfectly preserves the background and clothing without any artifacts.

• − Slightly alters the shape of the eyebrows and forehead compared to the source.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Captures a strong TV anchor newsroom aesthetic with a microphone and desk setup.
• + Maintains recognizable facial features from the source image in the caricature style.
• + Includes a cute dog companion as requested.

• − Completely misses the 'hockey' requirement.
• − Includes nonsensical text in the speech bubble.
• − Includes strange artifacts like a candle on the anchor desk.

Wan 2.7

• + Successfully incorporates all three themes: TV anchor, dogs, and hockey (puck, helmet, and rink).
• + Effectively captures the caricature 'big head' style while maintaining a good likeness of the subject.
• + Correctly renders legible English text in the speech bubbles.

• − The composition is a bit cluttered with multiple dogs and overlapping elements.
• − The transition from the 'real' arm into the cartoon body is slightly jarring.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent preservation of the original subjects' features and poses.
• + Captures a vibrant, modern anime aesthetic similar to high-budget features.
• + Maintains clear focal points and sharp details on the characters.

• − The 'sparkle' artifacts feel a bit distracting and less like a natural Ghibli texture.
• − The lighting is somewhat generic rather than the specific 'dreamy' quality requested.

Wan 2.7

• + Perfectly captures the hand-painted watercolor texture characteristic of Studio Ghibli backgrounds.
• + The soft, desaturated pastel color palette is highly accurate to the prompt.
• + Atmospheric, gentle lighting creates a more nostalgic mood than the competitor.

• − Slight loss of facial detail compared to the original photo.
• − The line work on the clothing is a bit more simplified.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully added a large number of falling leaves across the scene.
• + Followed the instruction to make the hair blow in the wind.
• + Maintained high image clarity and fidelity to the original background.

• − The blowing hair looks somewhat rigid and unnatural in its symmetry.
• − Some leaves appear to be floating statically rather than having motion blur.

Wan 2.7

• + The hair movement looks more natural and realistic.
• + Preserved the identity of the woman and the dog perfectly.
• + The added leaves feel better integrated into the 3D space of the scene.

• − The 'dynamic motion' effect is a bit subtle compared to Model A.
• − Fewer leaves were added, which slightly reduces the 'energetic' feel requested.