Qwen Image Edit 2511 Alibaba vs Vidu Q2 ShengShu Technology

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent preservation of the subject's unique hairstyle and plaid coat.
• + High-quality interior detail with realistic lighting on the dashboard.
• + Convincing composition showing the subject's face clearly while driving.

• − The car interior has changed brand/style significantly compared to the original white convertible.

Vidu Q2

• + Successfully keeps the specific exterior model of the white Rolls Royce from the source image.
• + Captures a wider cinematic view of the California coastline.
• + Good motion blur effect on the road to suggest driving.

• − The subject's facial features and hair are significantly altered and lose the detail of the source image.
• − The subject is wearing different clothes (all black) instead of the distinct plaid coat and scarf.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully adopts the background/environment style of Image 2.

• − Fails to follow the main instruction of swapping the characters, instead compositing both characters into one image.
• − Maintains the woman in the foreground in her original pose rather than replacing her with the man.
• − Poor anatomical scaling and integration of the two figures.

Vidu Q2

• + Successfully recreates the character from Image 2 in the exact pose from Image 1.
• + Retains key features from Image 2 including facial identity, sunglasses, scarf, and clothing style.
• + Accurately preserves the yellow studio environment from Image 1 as requested.

• − The extended right hand has some minor anatomical distortion (extra length/fingers).
• − The text on the shirt is slightly garbled compared to the source.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully replicates the entire pose and environment from a wider perspective.
• + Accurately places the scarf and coat layers onto the subject.

• − Failed to preserve the source person's face, hair, and vitiligo features entirely.
• − The subject is replaced with the man from Image 2 rather than the man from Image 1.
• − Lower image clarity and softer details compared to the original.

Vidu Q2

• + Successfully preserved the specific vitiligo patterns on the face and arms of the person from Image 1.
• + Higher visual fidelity and sharpness in the environment and textures.
• + Includes sunglasses and accessories as requested.

• − The right sleeve of the coat is missing, displaying the person's bare arm instead.
• − The sand on the coat appears slightly like an artifact rather than a natural interaction with the environment.
• − The pose was changed from leaning against the wood to standing straight.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent preservation of the source image facial features and glasses.
• + Natural integration of the hair with the original sideburns and beard.

• − The curly hair texture feels slightly less 'realistic' in its volume compared to local realism.

Vidu Q2

• + Highly realistic hair texture and natural-looking lighting on the hair strands.
• + Preserves the vast majority of the source image perfectly.

• − Slightly alters the shape of the upper forehead/brow bone area.
• − The hairline integration at the forehead is a bit sharp.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully captures the caricatured art style with an exaggerated head and expression.
• + Clearly depicts the TV anchor setting and includes a dog.
• + Maintains a recognizable likeness to the woman in the source image.

• − Completely misses the hockey requirement in the image.
• − Includes nonsensical text in the speech bubble and a candle on the desk which feels out of place.

Vidu Q2

• + Includes all elements of the prompt including dogs, news anchor theme, and hockey (goal, rink, puck).
• + Preserves the subject's original clothing (denim shirt over black top) more accurately.
• + High visual quality with clean lines and vibrant colors.

• − The hands are poorly rendered with an incorrect number of fingers and unnatural positioning.
• − The caricature effect is less pronounced than in a traditional caricature.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent preservation of the original subjects' faces and expressions.
• + Smooth digital painting style with a warm, nostalgic glow.

• − The style leans more towards modern manhua/anime rather than the specific Studio Ghibli aesthetic.
• − Added some distracting sparkling dust artifacts that were not requested.

Vidu Q2

• + Strong adherence to the Studio Ghibli aesthetic, particularly in the hand-painted watercolor textures and linework.
• + Accurately applies soft pastel colors and gentle lighting while maintaining the iconic meme composition.
• + Effective capture of Ghibli-style facial features (eyes and highlights).

• − The man's hand on his hip looks slightly more distorted than in the original.
• − Minor loss of detail in the background characters compared to Model A.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent depiction of wind-blown hair with high symmetry and aesthetic flow
• + Good preservation of the original subjects' faces and clothing
• + Leaves are subtly integrated into the scene

• − The hair transformation looks slightly stylized or 'painterly' compared to the photo realism of the original

Vidu Q2

• + Naturalistic hair movement that follows a single wind direction
• + Vibrant, high-contrast leaves that create a strong sense of depth
• + Excellent adherence to all prompts while maintaining photo consistency

• − Some leaves in the foreground are a bit blurry or distractingly large