GPT Image 2 OpenAI P-Image Edit PrunaAI

Settled by community votes across 2 shared challenges, with an AI judge weighing in on each.

GPT Image 2

28.1 arena score

#3 of 62 in Text-to-Image

Top 3 in Text-to-Image

Skill signature · Text-to-Image

P-Image Edit

9.5 arena score

#29 of 32 in Image Editing

Vote tally

Where the votes landed

GPT Image 2

win rate

Ties

P-Image Edit

win rate

Shared challenges 2

Challenge by challenge

The strongest take from each model on every shared challenge, with the AI judge's read.

Pose & Character Mashup

Editing

Edit instruction

“Use Image 1 as the exact pose reference and Image 2 as the character reference. Recreate the person/character from Image 2 in the exact dynamic pose and body position from Image 1. Keep the exact face, hair, clothing style/details, and expression from Image 2. Match the lighting and environment of Image 1. The final image must show the character from Image 2 performing the precise action/pose from Image 1 with perfect anatomy and natural integration.”

Source

GPT Image 2

P-Image Edit

AI Judge Analysis

GPT Image 2

+ Excellent adherence to the pose, including the specific foot placement on the ottoman.
+ Highly accurate character transfer, maintaining the clothing, scarf, and sunglasses from Image 2.
+ Consistent lighting and background matching the source environment.

− Slightly awkward integration of the scarf where it meets the sweatshirt.

P-Image Edit

+ Successfully combines the character's face and accessories with the pose.

− Fails to maintain the character's hair, blending it with the long hair from the pose reference.
− Incorrectly preserves the red color of the sweatshirt sleeves from Image 1 instead of switching to the character's black outfit.
− Anatomical errors in the pose, with legs and hands appearing distorted or misaligned.

Verdict: GPT Image 2 followed the instructions nearly perfectly, accurately mapping the character's face, hair, and clothing onto the complex pose from Image 1. P-Image Edit struggled with the character transfer, incorrectly keeping parts of the red sweatshirt and the long hair from the reference image, while also introducing anatomical artifacts.

Outfit Transfer Challenge

Editing

Edit instruction

“Use Image 1 as the base person. Dress them in the exact elaborate outfit from Image 2 (including all layers, accessories, jewelry, and shoes). Carefully adapt the clothing to the body shape and pose in Image 1 while maintaining realistic fabric behavior, correct proportions, and perfect lighting/shadow matching. Keep the person’s exact face, hair, and background completely unchanged.”

Source

GPT Image 2

P-Image Edit

AI Judge Analysis

GPT Image 2

+ Excellent preservation of the original person's face, hair, and vitiligo patterns
+ High-fidelity recreation of the coat and scarf textures from Image 2
+ Natural lighting and shadows that integrate the person into the scene

− Cropped the person differently, losing the full-body view and shoes
− Subtle changes to the background details around the wooden structure

P-Image Edit

+ Successfully adapted the full-body pose including shoes from the prompt's implied scope
+ Kept the person's face and unique vitiligo markings intact

− Added chunky gold jewelry and yellow laces not present in Image 2
− The clothing colors are significantly oversaturated compared to the source image
− Visual glitches around the left eye/eyebrow and distorted finger anatomy

Verdict: GPT Image 2 (Model A) provides a much higher quality edit by perfectly matching the textures and style of the reference clothing while maintaining the person's identity and skin patterns flawlessly. While it chooses a more zoomed-in composition, it avoids the anatomical errors and color inaccuracies found in P-Image Edit (Model B), which added non-existent accessories and suffered from severe oversaturation.