Head to head
Esc

Models · slot A

to navigate to pick

GPT-5.5 OpenAI Recraft V4 SVG Recraft AI

Settled by community votes across 6 shared challenges, with an AI judge weighing in on each.

GPT-5.5

-1.0 arena score

#5 of 5 in Text-to-Vector

Skill signature · Text-to-Vector

Recraft V4 SVG

30.5 arena score

#1 of 5 in Text-to-Vector

Best Text-to-Vector right now
Vote tally

Where the votes landed

GPT-5.5

0%

win rate

Ties

0%

Recraft V4 SVG

0%

win rate

Shared challenges 6

Challenge by challenge

The strongest take from each model on every shared challenge, with the AI judge's read.

The Nintendo Switch

Text-to-Vector

“Draw a Nintendo Switch”

GPT-5.5
Recraft V4 SVG

AI Judge Analysis

GPT-5.5

  • + Clean vector-style icon aesthetic
  • + Accurate representation of the Joy-Con color scheme
  • + Consistent and balanced button placement
  • Screen resolution is square rather than the accurate wide ratio
  • The logo on the screen is a generic interpretation

Recraft V4 SVG

  • + Includes labeled face buttons (X, Y, B, A)
  • + Vibrant, creative background art style
  • Colors are swapped with red on left and blue on right
  • Visual layout is cluttered with nonsensical geometric shapes
  • The analog sticks and D-pad are poorly rendered

Verdict: GPT-5.5 provides a much more coherent and recognizable depiction of the console despite the square screen, maintaining a clean professional aesthetic. Recraft V4 SVG attempts more detail with button labels but fails significantly on basic console layout and color orientation.

Pelican on a bike

Text-to-Vector

“Pelican riding a bicycle”

GPT-5.5
Recraft V4 SVG

AI Judge Analysis

GPT-5.5

  • + Features a simple, clean minimalist flat design.
  • + The pelican's feet are positioned somewhat realistically on the pedals.
  • + Colors are bright and consistent.
  • The bike anatomy is nonsensical with the handlebars floating apart from the frame.
  • The character looks more like a generic bird than specifically a pelican.

Recraft V4 SVG

  • + Excellent character design with additional details like a helmet, scarf, and sweater.
  • + The bicycle structure is much more coherent and recognizable.
  • + Vibrant color palette with clean, professional line work.
  • The bird's anatomy is highly anthropomorphized, appearing more like a person in a bird mask.
  • The beak is simplified and lacks the characteristic pelican pouch.

Verdict: Recraft V4 SVG delivers a much more polished and coherent illustration with a logical bicycle structure and charming character details. While GPT-5.5 is simpler, its failure to connect the bicycle handlebars to the frame makes it a significantly weaker image technically.

Cat drinking milk

Text-to-Vector

“A cat drinking milk by a morning window while a boy watches from outside, simple vector illustration”

GPT-5.5
Recraft V4 SVG

AI Judge Analysis

GPT-5.5

  • + Successfully positions the boy outside and the cat inside
  • + Captures a sunny morning atmosphere through lighting colors
  • + Strictly follows the vector illustration style
  • The cat's expression is aggressive/sinister which doesn't fit the scene
  • Poor character anatomy with the boy appearing to have no hands
  • The cat is standing over a bowl rather than drinking from it

Recraft V4 SVG

  • + High-quality, modern flat vector art style
  • + Clear narrative with the boy effectively looking in from outside
  • + Very clean lines and a pleasant color palette
  • The cat is holding a mug with hands like a human, which is a logic error
  • The liquid in the mug has steam, suggesting a hot drink rather than milk

Verdict: GPT-5.5 better handles the spatial logic of the prompt (cat on the floor, boy outside) but suffers from poor character design and a strange, angry expression on the cat. Recraft V4 SVG produces a much more professional and aesthetically pleasing vector illustration, though it takes a surreal approach by giving the cat human-like hands to hold a mug. Recraft V4 SVG is the preferred choice for its superior visual quality and artistic composition.

Robo-Logo

Text-to-Vector

“Minimalist vector logo of a friendly robot holding a coffee cup, clean lines, flat design, white background”

GPT-5.5
Recraft V4 SVG

AI Judge Analysis

GPT-5.5

  • + Excellent clean lines and aesthetic consistency for a vector logo.
  • + Clear, high-contrast character and object representation.
  • + Strict adherence to the requested minimalist flat design.
  • Simple interpretation that lacks the creative flair of additional typography.
  • The steam lines feel slightly disconnected from the mug.

Recraft V4 SVG

  • + Enhanced creativity with high-quality typography and a professional logo lockup.
  • + Stronger personality through a vibrant, complementary color palette.
  • + Excellent use of negative space for the robot's facial features.
  • The robot's arm holding the cup is abstract to the point of being unclear.
  • Flat design is slightly compromised by the complexity of the striped torso.

Verdict: GPT-5.5 provides a very literal and clean interpretation of a minimalist logo, making it highly versatile for basic icons. However, Recraft V4 SVG delivers a much more finished graphic design product with professional typography and a cohesive brand identity, even if the robot's physical form is more abstract. Recraft V4 SVG is preferred for its creative depth and polished font work.

Capybara Construction Worker

Text-to-Vector

“A Capybara steering an excavator”

GPT-5.5
Recraft V4 SVG

AI Judge Analysis

GPT-5.5

  • + Simple and clean vector-style illustration.
  • + Clear physical interaction with the steering wheel.
  • The character looks more like a generic bear than a capybara.
  • The excavator boom and bucket are simplified to the point of looking non-functional.

Recraft V4 SVG

  • + Strong artistic style with a bold color palette.
  • + Includes creative details like the worker's outfit and hat.
  • + The creature's facial profile more accurately resembles a capybara.
  • The capybara's fur color is white/grey which is unconventional.
  • The steering wheel is partially obscured and lacks the clear 'steering' action of the other image.

Verdict: Recraft V4 SVG delivers a much more sophisticated and stylistically consistent illustration compared to GPT-5.5. While GPT-5.5 shows the steering action more clearly, its character design fails to capture the specific identity of a capybara, looking more like a cartoon bear.

The Elephant Artist

Text-to-Vector

“Elephant painting a lighthouse”

GPT-5.5
Recraft V4 SVG

AI Judge Analysis

GPT-5.5

  • + Perfectly depicts an elephant using its trunk to paint on a canvas.
  • + Clean, minimalist vector aesthetic with a clear narrative.
  • + Colors are harmonious and the composition is balanced.
  • The character design is very basic and lacking in personality.
  • The palette under the elephant is just floating.

Recraft V4 SVG

  • + Unique, vibrant illustration style with high artistic merit.
  • + Clever interpretation of the elephant painting the actual structure rather than a canvas.
  • + High level of detail in the character design and secondary elements like the seagull.
  • The elephant is holding the brush with human-like hands/gloves rather than its trunk.
  • The anatomy of the elephant's multiple legs and hands is a bit surreal and cluttered.

Verdict: GPT-5.5 interprets the prompt literally as an artist painting a picture, resulting in a clear but simple image. Recraft V4 SVG takes a more creative approach by having the elephant paint the lighthouse structure itself, though it sacrifices biological accuracy by giving the elephant gloved hands. Recraft V4 SVG is the winner for its superior visual appeal, bold style, and imaginative composition.

Next steps

Explore each model