Nano Banana 2 Google vs Qwen Image Edit 2511 Alibaba

Nano Banana 2

• + Perfect preservation of the specific Rolls Royce car model from the source.
• + High consistency with the man's hair and facial features.
• + Cinematic composition showing the motion of the car on the coastline.

• − The man's outfit is partially simplified compared to the source.
• − The car appears to be right-hand drive while on a right-hand traffic road.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent preservation of the man's specific plaid jacket, scarf, and hairstyle.
• + The perspective creates an intimate 'in-the-car' feel.
• + High-quality rendering of hands on the steering wheel.

• − Failed to preserve the specific car brand/model (Rolls Royce) from the source image.
• − The interior dashboard design changed significantly from the source.

Nano Banana 2

• + Excellent adherence to the request, successfully placing the character from Image 2 in the pose and environment of Image 1.
• + High level of consistency in clothing, scarf, and face details from the character reference.
• + Natural-looking hands and feet that maintain the action of the source image.

• − The scarf's positioning is a bit awkward relative to gravity while leaning.
• − The right leg/foot connection to the Ottoman looks slightly detached.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully preserved the background of Image 2.

• − Failed the primary instruction by simply overlaying the two images rather than performing an edit.
• − Major anatomical and perspective errors caused by the collage-style approach.
• − Did not transfer the character to the new pose.

Nano Banana 2

• + Successfully preserved the unique vitiligo patterns on the person's face and hands.
• + Captured the specific accessories like the watch, ring, and sunglasses.
• + Maintained the original background and structure of the scene.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully added the full outfit including the boots.
• + Matching the lighting and fabric texture of the coat well.

• − Completely failed to preserve the base person, replacing them with a lookalike of the model from Image 2.
• − Ignored the specific vitiligo features which were core to the original subject.
• − Changed the character's pose significantly from the source.

Nano Banana 2

• + Excellent source preservation with no changes to facial structure or background.
• + Highly realistic hair texture that matches the age and facial hair of the subject.
• + Natural integration with the existing sideburns and temples.

• − None identified.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully followed the instruction to add a full head of hair.

• − The hair has a noticeably painterly, digital texture that contrasts with the photographic quality of the face.
• − The hairline and curly structure appear somewhat artificial and 'pasted on'.
• − Introduced subtle distortions to the shape of the glasses frame.

Nano Banana 2

• + Excellent adherence to all prompt elements including hockey and dogs.
• + High quality text rendering with clever puns like 'W-K9 NEWS'.
• + Strong resemblance to the source subject while maintaining caricature proportions.

• − The 'holding a photo' framing is a slight stylistic departure from a direct digital illustration.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully creates a caricature of the subject with exaggerated features.
• + Clear news anchor setting with a professional suit and microphone.

• − Completely misses the 'hockey' requirement.
• − Nonsensical text in the speech bubble and on the microphone.
• − Incoherent details like a lit candle next to a laptop.

Nano Banana 2

• + Perfectly captures the Studio Ghibli art style with watercolor textures and soft line work.
• + Preserves the iconic composition and poses while adding Ghibli-esque environmental details like flowers.
• + Excellent translation of facial expressions into an anime aesthetic.

• − The color of the dress was changed from a vibrant red to a more muted pinkish-peach.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Preserves the original colors and character features more accurately.
• + Successfully softens the lighting and applies a clean digital illustration style.

• − The art style is generic digital manhwa/webtoon rather than the requested Studio Ghibli style.
• − Lacks the 'hand-painted' texture specifically requested in the prompt.

Nano Banana 2

• + Strong prompt adherence with energetic windswept hair.
• + Expressive facial change adding to the 'energetic' feel.
• + Authentic leaf rendering with motion blur.

• − Noticeable change to the subject's face compared to the source image.
• − Added some dark artifacts/spots near the leaves by the flowers.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent preservation of the subject's original facial features.
• + Seamless hair extension that matches the wind effect.
• + Clean integration of colorful leaves.

• − The hair flow looks slightly more artificial/symmetrical compared to the source.
• − The energetic feel is slightly lower due to keeping the original posed expression.