FLUX.2 [pro] Black Forest Labs vs Qwen Image Edit 2511 Alibaba

FLUX.2 [pro]

• + Excellent preservation of the source car's specific model and details
• + Realistic motion blur on the wheels and road
• + Good integration of the man's face and distinctive hairstyle into the driver's seat

• − The man's clothing is simplified and doesn't fully match the plaid coat from the source
• − The man appears slightly small relative to the car

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Strong preservation of the man's specific outfit, including the plaid coat and scarf
• + Dynamic and clear view of the California coastline
• + Clean facial features and hair accuracy

• − The car interior and steering wheel do not match the Rolls-Royce from the source image
• − The perspective change completely removes the car's exterior, failing the preservation of the car source image

FLUX.2 [pro]

• + Successfully recreates the character's face, sunglasses, and outfit with high fidelity.
• + Accurately matches the lighting and environment (yellow background, red box) of Image 1.
• + Shows Good integration of the character into a physically plausible crouched/dynamic pose.

• − The pose is not an 'exact' match of Image 1, as the character is crouching rather than performing the specific limb extension.
• − The left arm and right hand show some anatomical awkwardness.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Retains both the original woman's pose and the male character in the background.
• + Maintains high resolution on both subjects.

• − Completely fails the core instruction to recreate the male character *in* the pose of the woman.
• − Simply composites the two images together poorly rather than performing a character/pose swap.
• − Fails to match the environment of Image 1, choosing the background of Image 2 instead.

FLUX.2 [pro]

• + Successfully added a thick head of hair while preserving most facial details.
• + The lighting on the top of the hair matches the sky light source well.

• − The hair is somewhat blurry and lacks the sharp, realistic texture found in the original beard.
• − The skin tone on the forehead was altered significantly, appearing lighter and smoother than the rest of the face.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent texture and density in the hair with sharp, realistic strands.
• + Near-perfect source preservation of the forehead texture, wrinkles, and original facial lighting.

• − The hairline transition on the left side (near the temple) is slightly abrupt.
• − The hair has a very specific curly style that may look slightly 'styled' rather than purely 'natural'.

FLUX.2 [pro]

• + Successfully incorporates all elements: tv anchor, dogs, and hockey in a cohesive scene.
• + Captures the subject's likeness well in a clean, professional vector caricature style.
• + Creative composition with the hockey rink desk and dogs in the background/foreground.

• − The style is more of a generic cartoon vector than a hand-drawn caricature.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Features a more 'exaggerated' and 'humorous' caricature style as requested.
• + Preserves the subject's hair and facial features accurately while distorting for comedic effect.

• − Completely missed the 'hockey' requirement of the prompt.
• − Contains nonsensical AI-generated text in the speech bubble.
• − Includes strange artifacts like a candle on a desk.

FLUX.2 [pro]

• + Excellent capture of the Studio Ghibli art style, including line work and watercolor textures.
• + Perfectly translates the expressions into a recognizable anime aesthetic.
• + Maintains the composition and iconic poses from the original meme accurately.

• − The color palette is slightly more washed out than a typical Ghibli frame.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully preserves the likeness and structure of the original image.
• + Clean, polished illustration style.

• − Does not capture the specific 'Ghibli' aesthetic, looking more like a generic modern digital illustration.
• − The lighting and textures lack the requested 'hand-painted' feel.

FLUX.2 [pro]

• + Excellent preservation of the woman's face and original features.
• + Highly realistic integration of falling leaves with naturalistic textures.
• + Subtle and effective wind effect on the hair.

• − Some leaves appear to be stuck in the dog's mouth and chest rather than flying in the air.
• − The jacket lapels lost some structure during the edit.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Stronger, more dramatic wind effect on the hair that suggests more movement.
• + Better distribution of flying leaves throughout the scene without obscuring the subjects.
• + Maintains the dog's appearance perfectly while adding a motion-blurred tail.

• − The woman's face underwent slight changes, particularly around the jawline and smile, compared to the source.
• − A small artifact/floating leaf bit appeared near the woman's left hand.