FLUX.2 [dev] Black Forest Labs vs Qwen Image Edit 2511 Alibaba

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Successfully merges the car's interior aesthetic (white leather/wood trim) with the coastal environment.
• + Maintains the man's hairstyle and clothing textures with high fidelity.
• + Captures a cinematic lighting and motion blur effect on the road.

• − The man's face shape and features have changed significantly from the source image.
• − The hand on the steering wheel has anatomical issues with finger placement.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent preservation of the man's facial features and smiling expression from the source.
• + Perfectly captures the 'California coastline' vibe with palm trees and a winding coastal highway.
• + Strong rendering of hands on the steering wheel.

• − The car interior is less consistent with the source Rolls Royce, appearing slightly more generic.
• − The proportions of the man's head relative to the car seat seem slightly enlarged.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Attempts to merge the character's clothing and appearance into a single figure.
• + Successfully replicates the yellow background and red ottoman from Image 1.
• + Captures the character's face, sunglasses, and scarf from Image 2.

• − Horrific anatomical failure with a second head and distorted limbs.
• − Does not mimic the pose from Image 1 accurately, creating a floating composite instead.
• − Severe artifacts and lack of structural coherence.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Near-perfect preservation of the woman's pose and clothing from Image 1.
• + High resolution and clean edges on the subject.

• − Completely failed the core instruction to replace the person with the character from Image 2.
• − Just placed the character from Image 2 as a static background layer behind the original person.
• − Kept the background from Image 2 instead of Image 1.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Successfully replicates the specific scarf pattern and pea coat style from Image 2.
• + Maintains the vitiligo pattern and unique blond hair patch from the person in Image 1.
• + Keeps the 'INNERSY' waistband detail from the original subject's underwear.

• − Blends the facial features of the person in Image 2 with the person in Image 1, failing the 'exact face' instruction.
• − The hand in the pocket has a blurry, distorted appearance.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Accurately incorporates the shoes/boots as requested in the instructions.
• + Good full-body integration with the background environment.

• − Completely fails to preserve the identity of the person in Image 1, removing their vitiligo and facial structure.
• − Fails to keep the background completely unchanged, adding extra sand texture and modifying the post.
• − Changes the hairstyle significantly from the source image person.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent preservation of the original face, glasses, and background
• + Extremely realistic hair texture and fine strands

• − The 'afro' style chosen is a significant departure from the original subject's likely natural hair type
• − The hair obscures a portion of the original sky and background

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Natural-looking wavy hair that matches the existing beard texture well
• + Perfect preservation of the original face and surrounding environment

• − The lighting on top of the hair is slightly flatter than the high-contrast lighting of the original scene

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Strongly incorporates all prompt elements including dogs, a news desk, and a hockey rink background.
• + Maintains a recognizable likeness to the original subject while applying the caricature style.
• + High level of detail in the background, including a camera crew and multiple dogs in hockey jerseys.

• − Text on the desk is nonsensical gibberish.
• − The inclusion of the male caricature in the top left is slightly confusing in the context of the user's request.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully captures a high-energy, exaggerated facial expression appropriate for a caricature.
• + Clear and clean vector-like art style.

• − Completely fails to incorporate the requested hockey theme.
• − The text in the speech bubble is unintelligible.
• − The inclusion of a lit candle on the desk is a strange, unrelated artifact.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Captures the Studio Ghibli art style more authentically with hand-painted textures and soft line art.
• + Successfully implements a 'dreamy' background as requested in the prompt.
• + The color palette is very soft and nostalgic.

• − Replaces the background entirely, losing the urban street setting of the source image.
• − The foreground woman's red dress is faded to pink, deviating significantly from the source colors.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Excellent source preservation, keeping the urban street, the bus, and background pedestrians intact.
• + Accurately translates the original facial expressions and likeness into an illustrated style.
• + The lighting effects align well with the warm, nostalgic atmosphere requested.

• − The art style is more generic 'manhwa/webtoon' than Studio Ghibli.
• − Some digital artifacts or 'sparkles' feel out of place for a hand-painted aesthetic.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent addition of high-detail autumn leaves that fit the environment's color palette.
• + Successfully blew the hair outward in a natural-looking motion.
• + High source preservation including the woman's face and dog's features.

• − The hair edges look slightly fuzzy or disconnected in some areas.

Qwen Image Edit 2511

• + Successfully applied wind effect to both the woman's hair and the dog's fur.
• + Leaves are well-distributed throughout the frame to suggest a gust of wind.
• + Maintains the identity of the woman and the dog very well.

• − The added hair strands have a somewhat 'liquified' or smoothed look compared to the source texture.
• − A leaf appears to be growing out of the dog's back.