FLUX.2 [dev] Black Forest Labs vs P-Image Edit PrunaAI

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent preservation of the man's clothing, hairstyle, and facial features from the source image.
• + Accurately recreates the interior details and leather seating of the Rolls Royce Phantom Drophead Coupe.

• − The perspective of the car's body in the foreground feels slightly disconnected from the interior view.
• − The lighting on the man's face is quite dark compared to the bright beach background.

P-Image Edit

• + Successfully translates the car from a showroom to a motion shot on a coastline road.
• + Preserves the overall exterior look and angle of the car from the source image very well.

• − The man is barely visible and lacks the specific details (plaid coat, scarf) from the source image.
• − The scale of the man inside the car looks slightly too small.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Successfully incorporates the character's clothing, scarf, and sunglasses.
• + Maintains the central yellow background and red ottoman.

• − Extreme anatomical failure with a second head and distorted limbs.
• − Fails to replicate the dynamic pose, opting for a static upright torso superimposed on the scene.
• − Severe artifacting and blending issues between the character and the background elements.

P-Image Edit

• + Captures a much better approximation of the dynamic pose and body position from Image 1.
• + Successfully incorporates the specific character features like the sunglasses and scarf.
• + Integrated the character's face onto the tilted head position with logical orientation.

• − Anatomy is still flawed, particularly with the placement of legs and the extra foot in the air.
• − Confusion in clothing where black sleeves transition into red sleeves.
• − Hair style from Image 2 was not preserved, instead keeping the long hair from Image 1.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Successfully captures the texture and pattern of the scarf and pea coat from Image 2.
• + Maintains high resolution and realistic lighting that blends the figure with the beach background.

• − Fails significantly on source preservation by replacing the face and hair of the man in Image 1 with the man from Image 2.
• − Over-complicates the prompt by adding several large gold chains not present in either source image.

P-Image Edit

• + Excellent source preservation, keeping the exact face, unique hair pattern, and skin markings of the person in Image 1.
• + Generally follows the clothing transfer request while adapting the items to the full-body pose.

• − The color of the coat shifted from a dark navy/charcoal to a bright royal blue.
• − The gold chains and yellow-laced shoes are hallucinations not found in Image 2.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent preservation of the original face, lighting, and background.
• + Realistic hair texture and density that blends well with the existing beard.
• + Maintains the exact geometry of the eyeglasses.

• − The afro-style choice is a bit voluminous, though it fits the prompt's request for 'full and thick'.

P-Image Edit

• + Successfully adds a full head of hair.
• + Preserves the original facial features and environment accurately.

• − The hair texture has 'infinite loop' artifacts where curls repeat unnaturally.
• − The hairline integration at the forehead looks slightly less blending than the other model.
• − The hair rendering looks somewhat more synthetic/plastic compared to the beard.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent caricature style with exaggerated proportions.
• + Effectively integrates all themes including profession (anchor desk), dogs, and hockey simultaneously.
• + Strong character likeness to the source image face.

• − Text on the desk is garbled and unreadable.
• − The hand holding the pen has anatomical issues with the fingers.

P-Image Edit

• + Successfully incorporates the 'tv show' and 'hockey' elements into a cohesive scene.
• + Maintains character likeness while translating the persona into a vibrant cartoon style.
• + Preserves the denim jacket style from the original source image.

• − The 'dogs' requirement is poorly executed, featuring strange, non-organic red shapes on the dog.
• − The overall composition feels a bit cluttered with nonsensical small objects on the desk.
• − Less of a 'caricature' and more of a standard comic illustration.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Expertly captures the soft, matte, hand-painted texture typical of Studio Ghibli backgrounds.
• + Excellent application of pastel colors and dreamy, warm lighting that matches the prompt perfectly.
• + Maintains the composition and recognizable poses of the original meme flawlessly.

• − The characters' eyes are a bit simplified, leaning slightly more towards generic anime than a specific Ghibli face style.

P-Image Edit

• + Preserves the facial features and expressions of the source image with high accuracy.
• + Successfully translates the scene into a colorful, dreamy illustrated environment.

• − The art style feels more like a modern digital vector illustration than the requested 'hand-painted' Ghibli style.
• − The lighting is a bit harsher and less 'nostalgic' compared to the first model.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent preservation of the subject's face and original features.
• + Realistic, detailed autumn leaves added with natural lighting.
• + Effective wind effect on the hair that looks physically plausible.

• − The leaf placement looks slightly clustered on the left side of the frame.

P-Image Edit

• + Successfully applied the wind effect to the hair and added flying leaves.
• + Maintains high similarity to the original source image structure.

• − The hair edit creates some unnatural, thin 'stringy' artifacts on the right side.
• − Added leaves are very small and look more like simple yellow/orange dots than detailed foliage.
• − Noticeable softening or slight alteration of the facial features compared to the source.