FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8 Black Forest Labs vs Qwen Image Alibaba

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Excellent refraction and caustic effects through the glass
• + High resolution and sharp details on the sphere and table texture
• + Accurate soft lighting and depth of field

• − The glass container is more of a tall rectangular prism than a 'cube'
• − The sphere is levitating on an internal shelf rather than resting on the bottom

Qwen Image

• + Perfect adherence to the 'cube' shape
• + Realistic placement of the sphere at the bottom of the cube
• + Clean, balanced composition

• − Lighting is a bit flat compared to Model A
• − The plant lacks the refraction/visibility through the glass requested in the prompt
• − Minor structural artifacts in the internal glass reflections

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Excellent skin texture and facial details
• + Strong reflection rendering on the wet asphalt
• + Vivid colors and high cinematic quality

• − Missed the 'motion blur' request for the background vehicles
• − The man appears to be posing with/holding the bike rather than actively repairing it
• − The background sign language and car logos are slightly garbled

Qwen Image

• + Better adherence to the requested motion blur of passing cars
• + More accurate representation of light rain with visible falling droplets
• + Authentic Japanese street atmosphere

• − The bike has anatomical/mechanical errors, specifically the pedal and kickstand logic
• − Skin textures are slightly smoother and less detailed than model A
• − The subject's hands are somewhat blurry and lack definition

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Exceptional skin texture and lifelike eye detail
• + Excellent implementation of torchlight reflection on the face and armor
• + Superior close-up composition with high cinematic appeal

• − Missed the request for 'hair braided with small beads'
• − Armor and leather details are partially obscured by the tight framing

Qwen Image

• + Strong adherence to all prompt elements including braided hair with beads and leather straps
• + Clearly visible ornate engraved plate armor
• + Good inclusion of bokeh sparks and a physical torch

• − Skin and hair texture look slightly artificial and plastic-like
• − Lighting is less integrated with the subject compared to Model A
• − Scars look like surface paint rather than realistic wounds

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Cluttered but realistic layout that looks like a functional two-page menu.
• + Includes specific sections for pizza and mains as requested.
• + Clean white background with professional alignment of text and prices.

• − Text contains frequent misspellings like 'ORCETERS' and 'APPTIZERS'.
• − The food photos lack the 'vibrant' pop requested, looking somewhat muted and repetitive.
• − The 'grid' requested is applied to the whole page rather than being a distinct design element for photos.

Qwen Image

• + Strong adherence to the 'grid' and 'vibrant accents' request with colorful backgrounds for photos.
• + Excellent bold sans-serif typography that feels truly modern and minimalist.
• + High-quality, appetizing food photography that fits the casual dining vibe.

• − Failed to provide a distinct section for 'mains', grouping them with pizza instead.
• − Text rendering becomes illegible in the smaller menu item descriptions.
• − One grid cell is just a solid orange block with garbled text rather than a photo.

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Naturalistic bun texture and lighting on the food
• + Good use of negative space for the central subject

• − Severely failed text rendering with multiple spelling errors and repetitions
• − Incorrect price was featured prominently (€69 vs €6.99)
• − Minimal 'fiery' effect on the text itself

Qwen Image

• + Excellent adherence to styling with fiery, glowing text effects
• + Perfect text accuracy including the currency and secondary message
• + Highly dynamic composition with various exploded ingredients

• − The burger structure is a bit more 'stacked' than 'exploded' compared to the pieces in the air
• − Slight overlap of the starburst and the burger bun

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Excellent realistic chalk texture on the board.
• + Good adherence to the request for natural variations in letter size.

• − Numerous spelling errors including 'Risortto', 'Griffled', and 'Octemon'.
• − Text layout is cluttered with repetitive lines and messy price alignment.

Qwen Image

• + Near-perfect spelling of complex menu items.
• + Consistent and aesthetically pleasing handwriting style across the board.
• + Great background composition that establishes the cozy café setting.

• − Small error in the date, rendering '20026' instead of '2026'.
• − The text appears slightly too perfect/digital compared to the requested raw chalk texture.

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Attempts the specific role-reversal requested in the prompt
• + High level of texture detail on the horse hair and equipment
• + Dramatic cinematic lighting and composition

• − Anatomy becomes messy with two horse heads and fused bodies
• − The 'astronaut' is represented as equipment rather than a clear figure

Qwen Image

• + High clarity and clean rendering
• + Good anatomical representation of a horse
• + Consistent lighting

• − Completely ignores the negative constraint that the horse should be on top
• − Produces a generic interpretation of the prompt

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Excellent texture on the capybara's fur.
• + Consistent interior lighting with the yellow cab theme.
• + Successfully captures the 'bored' expression of the passenger.

• − The passenger is holding two phones simultaneously, which is a hallucination.
• − The taxi cap is a small plastic-looking piece rather than a traditional driver's hat.
• − The passenger is on the wrong side relative to the driver for a standard taxi.

Qwen Image

• + Features a more authentic taxi driver cap and professional jacket.
• + Proper placement of the passenger in the back seat with a realistic bored expression.
• + Higher realism in the vehicle's interior hardware and framing.

• − The capybara's hands/paws look slightly mutated and more like primate hands.
• − Text on the roof sign is garbled ('YOXI').

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Features a vibrant, glowing jack-o-lantern.
• + Captures the 'dark parchment' texture well in the border.

• − Severely garbled text and typos throughout the invitation details.
• − Missed the specific requested border elements like spider webs.

Qwen Image

• + Excellent adherence to border details, including webs and thorns.
• + Perfectly rendered event details at the bottom with no typos.
• + Stronger gothic aesthetic with twisted trees and cinematic lighting.

• − Small typo in the main header text ('Halle Party' instead of 'Halloween Party').

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Excellent 3D modeling effect with soft, clean textures
• + Perfectly executed 45-degree isometric perspective
• + High clarity and centered composition on a professional diorama base

• − Failed the text prompt, spelling 'JAPAN' and 'JAPAN' (with a dot) instead of 'SUSHI'
• − The flag icon is integrated into the text incorrectly

Qwen Image

• + Perfect adherence to text instructions including 'JAPAN' and 'SUSHI'
• + Includes the flag icon as requested in both the text area and the scene
• + Accurate representation of the diorama and miniature cartoon style balance

• − Chopsticks are slightly melded into the rest of the plate
• − Background color is a bit saturated for 'solid light blue' compared to Model A

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Warm and vibrant lighting with effective god rays
• + High fur detail and texture
• + Great atmospheric depth with blurred foreground wildflowers

• − Failed to include a bunny, substituting it with extra cats/unidentified kits
• − The animal grouping looks congested and slightly unnatural
• − One cat has a noticeably distorted mouth expression

Qwen Image

• + Successfully included all four requested animals (dog, cat, bunny, fox)
• + Clearer 'chasing' action and dynamic posing
• + Better adherence to the 'dew sparkles' instruction with visible bokeh highlights

• − The fox's front paws look a bit like dark blobs or shadows
• − Lighting is a bit flatter compared to the intense golden glow of Model A

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Strong vintage aesthetic with detailed scrollwork
• + Colors are well-balanced and authentic to the retro theme
• + Includes the 'Est. 1720' text clearly

• − Major spelling error in the main brand name ('Afe Flamilan')
• − The cloche looks more like a building dome than a food cloche

Qwen Image

• + Successfully rendered the cloche dome with steam
• + Minimalist vector style aligns well with the prompt
• + Text is closer to the correct spelling despite layout issues

• − Text layout is cluttered and difficult to read ('FloraiAN')
• − The typography lacks the 'classic' elegance requested in the prompt

FLUX.1 [schnell] FP8

• + Excellent adherence to the 'flat-vector' style with crisp lines and balanced weight.
• + Sophisticated, professional layout that feels like a real educational infographic.
• + Strong adherence to the requested NASA-inspired color palette.

• − Text is mostly gibberish or nonsensical placeholder-style characters.
• − Confused the specific steps, only showing 5 main icons for 6 requested steps.
• − Iconography is a bit abstract and doesn't clearly represent the Saturn V rocket.

Qwen Image

• + High degree of legibility for step titles and names.
• + Correctly followed the numeric sequence of steps (though mislabeled some).
• + Individual icons like the Lunar Module and Saturn V are more recognizable as the objects described.

• − Poor composition with overlapping elements and a cluttered, non-linear flow.
• − Failed to follow the logical sequence of the mission (e.g., placing the Landing before the LEM on the surface).
• − Included the prompt text 'Stop at landing' as a header in the image itself.