Vidu Q2 ShengShu Technology vs Wan 2.7 Pro Alibaba

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent depiction of sunlight and shadows.
• + Highly realistic glass reflections and refractions of the plant behind it.
• + Very sharp textures on the book and wooden table.

• − The glass cube has an open top or missing side, as the book appears to be resting on thin glass edges with no solid top surface visible.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Perfect adherence to all spatial instructions in the prompt.
• + Naturalistic lighting from the window on the left as requested.
• + Realistic material textures for the weathered wooden table.

• − The sphere's texture is slightly mottled/marbled rather than a solid blue sphere.
• − The glass cube has some internal vertical lines that look more like structural pillars than pure glass panes.

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent preservation of the man's facial features and hair style from the source image.
• + Accurately places the man behind the steering wheel in a driving position.
• + High degree of consistency for the Rolls Royce design and color.

• − The sense of speed on the road looks a bit stylized/blurred compared to the static car.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Beautiful landscape composition that looks like an authentic California coastline.
• + Good preservation of the vehicle details.

• − Compleately failed to preserve the man's identity, replacing him with a generic individual.
• − The person is positioned in the passenger seat instead of the driver's seat.
• − The wheels on the car and the road lines have some perspective warping.

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent depiction of skin texture and veins
• + Realistic wear and tear on the bicycle frame
• + Successfully captures the 'imperfect framing' and 'candid' feel requested

• − Significant anatomical errors in the hands and number of fingers
• − Structural issues with the bicycle chain and pedal placement
• − Lacks the requested motion blur on the background car

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Better overall composition and sense of place
• + More coherent bicycle structure compared to Model A
• + Good lighting and reflections on the wet pavement

• − The image is too clean and lacks the requested motion blur
• − The 'rain' is barely visible as fine noise rather than actual droplets or streaks
• − Slightly less 'candid' as the framing feels very centered and deliberate

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent depiction of ornate engraved plate armor with high detail
• + Strong adherence to lighting prompts with warm torchlight reflections
• + Very high textural resolution on the leather straps and metal surfaces

• − The character looks a bit too pristine and 'model-like' for a battle-worn warrior
• − The hair braiding is simple compared to the beads requested

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Perfect interpretation of hair braided with small beads
• + Captures the 'battle-worn' aesthetic more convincingly with realistic facial weathering
• + Excellent bokeh sparks and background atmospheric depth

• − The leather strap across the chest lacks the crisp high-definition texture seen in the other model
• − Metal engraving is slightly less intricate than model A

Vidu Q2

• + Successfully includes the requested vibrant accents.
• + Maintains a high-key, clean white background.

• − Text is largely gibberish or heavily distorted, making it unusable as a menu.
• − Layout is chaotic with overlapping sections and inconsistent column widths.
• − The grid layout requested is poorly executed compared to the competitor.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Excellent typography with mostly legible English text and coherent menu items.
• + Strict adherence to the requested grid layout with professional spacing.
• + Higher realism in food photography that matches the category labels.

• − The 'sides' and 'drinks' categories were not explicitly requested in the prompt, though they fit the context.
• − Text still contains minor spelling errors ('Bissue', 'Alferdo', 'Riautto').

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent photorealistic texture on the burger bun and patty
• + Text integration feels naturally blended with the fire and lighting
• + Dynamic and chaotic splashing sauce adds to the motion feel

• − The currency symbol is incorrect, showing a crossed 'E' rather than a standard Euro symbol
• − The burger ingredients are somewhat clumped together rather than being fully 'exploded'

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Perfect adherence to all text requirements including the Euro symbol and starburst
• + Superior 'exploded' layout with clearly separated ingredients like onions and cucumbers
• + Professional graphic design balance and cleaner background composition

• − Texture on the cheese and patty looks slightly more plastic/CG than Model A
• − The flying herbs look a bit repetitive and flat

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent realistic chalk texture on the lettering
• + Authentic smudging and chalkboard residue across the surface

• − Significant spelling errors throughout the menu items
• − Price on the first item is incorrect based on the prompt

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Perfect adherence to the requested text and prices
• + Very clean and readable composition
• + Excellent background environment with warm lighting

• − Handwriting looks slightly more like a digital font than natural chalk variations
• − The chalk texture is very uniform and lacks the grit seen in Model A

Vidu Q2

• + Successfully integrated character features from Image 2 including facial likeness, sunglasses, and the scarf.
• + Precise adaptation of the complex body pose from Image 1.
• + High visual clarity and sharp detail preservation in the face.

• − The hands are severely distorted with extra fingers and unnatural anatomy.
• − The lighting transition from the character onto the background is slightly harsh.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Perfectly preserved the original background and composition of Image 1.

• − Completely failed the edit instruction to change the character to the subject of Image 2.
• − Maintained the woman from the source image instead of performing the character swap.

Vidu Q2

• + Vibrant, cosmic color palette with beautiful galaxy details
• + Dynamic, energetic pose for both horse and rider

• − Failed to follow the contradictory instruction of 'horse on top'
• − Anatomical issues with the horse's rear right leg connecting poorly to the body

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Naturalistic and clean lighting on the astronaut suit
• + Good use of planetary elements in the background

• − Failed to follow the contradictory instruction of 'horse on top'
• − The horse's legs are thin and have inconsistent anatomy
• − Less 'surreal' or 'cinematic' than the other model, feeling more like a basic collage

Vidu Q2

• + Successfully transferred the pea coat, scarf, and accessories (watch, glasses) from the reference image.
• + Maintained the color and pattern accuracy of the plaid scarf.
• + Integrated the face and skin of the original subject fairly well despite some changes.

• − Failed to keep the face and hair completely unchanged, adding a mustache and altering features.
• − The background and overall composition have been significantly altered rather than preserved.
• − Strange sand-like textures are appearing over the clothing and skin.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Successfully preserved the original person's facial features and the background environment.
• + Captured a full-body view that attempts to include the shoes as requested.
• + Realistic shadow and lighting integration with the surroundings.

• − Completely failed to use the correct outfit from Image 2, choosing a gold/black patterned suit instead of the blue pea coat and scarf.
• − Lost much of the vitiligo detail on the subject's torso by covering it with a different pattern.
• − Poor garment draping and proportion on the legs.

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent adherence to the scene layout with the passenger correctly positioned in the back seat.
• + High photographic realism in the car interior and lighting.
• + The capybara's expression and posture perfectly match the 'professional' and 'paws on wheel' instructions.

• − The passenger's phone is slightly distorted.
• − The yellow cap is a bit stiff/plastic-looking compared to the fur.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Excellent fur texture on the capybara's head.
• + Good depiction of the bored expression on the businesswoman.

• − Failed the spatial layout by placing the passenger in the front passenger seat instead of the back seat.
• − The paws on the steering wheel look more like primate/human hands than capybara paws.
• − The seatbelt passes through the capybara's neck in a physically impossible way.

Vidu Q2

• + Features very cinematic lighting on the jack-o-lantern and parchment texture
• + Includes the thorns and twisted trees around the border as requested

• − Significant spelling errors in the title and banner text
• − Failed to render the correct date (2025 instead of 2026)
• − The 'night sky' is only visible behind the scroll edges, making the composition feel cramped

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Excellent text rendering with near-perfect spelling for all requested lines
• + Highly detailed composition with a clear night sky, moon, and multiple layers
• + Strong adherence to all prompt elements including the specific date and location

• − The art style is more like a clean digital illustration than a 'vintage' gothic poster
• − Less atmospheric 'dark parchment' feel compared to the other model

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent preservation of the source background and clothing.
• + The hair texture and lighting match the environment very well.
• + Produces a very thick, full head of hair as requested.

• − The hairline is a bit low and looks slightly like a hairpiece due to the hard edge.
• − The hair is styled in a way that feels a bit unnatural for the character's rugged look.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Natural and realistic hairline that blends well with the forehead.
• + The messy, wavy style fits the rugged aesthetic of the character and scene.
• + Perfect preservation of facial features and textures.

• − The hair feels slightly less 'thick' or 'full' compared to Model A, appearing a bit flat on top.
• − Slight blurring where the hair meets the background sky.

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent 3D miniature felt/clay aesthetic
• + Strong, bold typography that is easy to read
• + Includes a creative flag interpretation integrated with the text

• − The diorama base is a bit small for the plate
• − Slightly less realistic PBR material properties on the fish compared to model b

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Very clean, high-clarity isometric composition
• + Superior PBR material rendering with realistic subsurface scattering on the sushi
• + Sophisticated typography and professional layout

• − Includes extra elements like chopsticks and soy sauce not requested in the 'minimal' prompt
• − Floating artifacts in the top corners of the image

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent character likeness to the source person.
• + Clever integration of all themes with a news desk set on an ice rink.
• + Preserves the original clothing (denim shirt and black t-shirt).

• − Anatomical issue with the right hand holding the microphone.
• − Minor rendering artifacts in the background mesh of the hockey goal.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Successfully incorporates all prompt elements including pets and hockey team spirit.
• + Clean caricature style with clear text rendering.
• + Good composition with centered subject and background TV.

• − Loses the specific facial likeness of the source image.
• − Changed the character's clothing entirely from the source image.
• − The hockey stick/microphone hybrid is a bit strange visually.

Vidu Q2

• + Bright and vibrant meadow with beautiful god rays
• + Captures the 'tumbling' and interactive energy requested
• + High detail on the individual flowers and butterfly wings

• − Generated two golden retriever puppies instead of the requested one
• − Anatomical issues on the fox's hind legs
• − Butterflies are repeated and look less integrated

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + High degree of photorealism and fur texture
• + Correct counting of the requested animals (one of each)
• + Excellent composition focusing on the central interaction

• − Fox kit looks slightly older/larger than the other 'baby' animals
• − The kitten's pose is a bit awkward against the puppy's side

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent character design that authentically mimics the Ghibli anime style.
• + Strong, clean line work typical of animated films.
• + Maintains the distinct facial expressions and poses from the source image effectively.

• − The background is a bit generic and lacks the intricate hand-painted detail Ghibli is known for.
• − Colors are somewhat flat compared to a traditional watercolor aesthetic.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Beautiful watercolor texture that captures the hand-painted feel of Ghibli background art.
• + Soft, warm, and nostalgic color palette is very accurate to the prompt.
• + Superior integration of characters into a dreamy, painterly environment.

• − The faces lean slightly more toward realism than the classic Ghibli character aesthetic.
• − Some minor loss of clarity in the line work due to the heavy texture.

Vidu Q2

• + Excellent preservation of the woman's face and original features.
• + Highly effective interpretation of hair blowing in the wind.
• + Substantial number of leaves added to create a sense of environment.

• − The leaves feel somewhat flat and disconnected from the depth of the scene.
• − A small artifact is present on the dog's leash where it meets the hand.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + The hair motion is very dynamic and realistic, spreading naturally.
• + The lighting on the dog and path is well-preserved.
• + Leaves are integrated better into the scene's depth, with some appearing on the ground/grass.

• − The woman's facial features were slightly altered, especially around the eyes.
• − Fewer leaves overall compared to the 'dynamic' request.
• − A slight blur or ghosting artifact on some of the flying leaves.

Vidu Q2

• + Clean vector-style coloring
• + Effective use of warm brown and cream tones
• + Correct cloche dome and steam iconography

• − Severe spelling hallucinations in the brand name
• − Messy typography with inconsistent letter shapes
• − Repeated text elements at the bottom

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + High-quality vintage illustrative style
• + Excellent typography with accurate spelling of 'Est. 1720'
• + Cohesive round emblem composition

• − Slight misspelling of the name as 'Florion' instead of 'Florian'
• − Includes stray decorative elements in the corners not mentioned in the prompt

Vidu Q2

• + Clean vector illustration style
• + Includes all major requested visual components like the lunar module and planetary bodies

• − Text is largely gibberish and incoherent
• − Layout is disorganized and doesn't follow a logical timeline order
• − Failed to use the specific NASA-inspired navy palette as the primary background

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Excellent text rendering with accurate names and mission details
• + Perfect adherence to the requested steps and chronological flow
• + Strong color palette usage and professional infographic layout

• − Small typo in 'Descent' (rendered as DESCRIPT)
• − Minor artifacting on the NASA logo in the bottom corner