Recraft V4.1 Pro Recraft AI vs Wan 2.6 Alibaba

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent texture on the book cover and wood grain
• + Highly convincing glass reflections and refraction
• + Clean, modern photographic aesthetic

• − The glass cube appears to be missing its top panel, making the book look like it is floating or resting on thin edges

Wan 2.6

• + Accurately depicts the plant behind the glass with realistic refraction
• + Strong adherence to the lighting prompt with clear window light from the left
• + Features a solid, closed glass cube structure

• − The book and sphere appear slightly low-resolution or painterly compared to the environment
• − Some distortion where the glass meets the table surface

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent depiction of motion blur from passing cars
• + Strong adherence to the 'imperfect framing' and 'candid' aspects of the prompt
• + Highly realistic skin texture and lighting that feels like a genuine film photograph

• − The red bicycle is partially cropped out of the frame
• − The hands and the specific interaction with the bike are somewhat obscured

Wan 2.6

• + Beautiful composition and lighting with prominent wet pavement reflections
• + Detailed rendering of tools and the mechanical parts of the bike
• + Excellent portrayal of age in the man's face and hands

• − Raindrops on the man's jacket look more like static crystal beads than dynamic water
• − The 'motion blur' on the passing car is quite subtle compared to the prompt's request
• − The scene feels slightly staged rather than a 'candid street photo'

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Exceptional high-resolution skin texture that shows pores and natural blemishes.
• + Intricate and precise engraving on the plate armor with believable metallic luster.
• + Perfect adherence to the braid and bead requirement with realistic hair integration.

• − The eyes, while detailed, look slightly glassy and unnatural in their color.
• − The bokeh shapes are a bit busy and can distract from the main subject.

Wan 2.6

• + Excellent narrative lighting with visible torches contributing to the warm atmosphere.
• + Very strong adherence to the 'battle-worn' descriptor with realistic skin abrasions.
• + Good interpretation of the leather straps and cloth underlayer textures.

• − The hair beads look somewhat like digital overlays rather than being woven into the hair.
• − Overall image sharpness and microscopic detail are lower than the competitor.

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent text legibility with almost perfect spelling and professional typography.
• + Highly professional layout that looks like a real-world design asset.
• + Correct representation of all requested sections including Appetizers, Pizza, and Mains.

• − The grid of photos is a bit sparse compared to a full gallery view.
• − Minor spelling error in 'sraalmon'.

Wan 2.6

• + Strong adherence to the colorful food photos in a grid layout.
• + Vibrant color accents used consistently across the border and headers.
• + Good image quality for the food photographs.

• − Text is largely illegible gibberish, failing basic typography standards.
• − The content of the food grid is repetitive, showing mostly pizzas even in non-pizza sections.
• − Misspelled 'RESTAUR' in the main header.

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Clean and readable text layout with excellent fiery effects on the lettering.
• + Very high-quality food textures, especially on the meat patty and sesame bun.
• + Dynamic sauce splash adds a great sense of motion and 'suspended' physics.

• − The background is slightly more simplified compared to the intense atmosphere requested.
• − The starburst for the price is more of an explosion than a traditional graphic element.

Wan 2.6

• + Exceptional atmospheric background with realistic smoke, fire, and embers.
• + The 'MAGIC BURGER' title is beautifully integrated with 3D depth and flames.
• + Great use of a literal starburst graphic for the price as is common in advertising.

• − The burger is less 'exploded' than Model A, with many components still resting on each other.
• − The bottom text is partially obscured by the fire at the base of the frame.

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent text legibility and accuracy
• + Clean composition with consistent handwriting style
• + Followed the prompt instructions for the price of the third item perfectly

• − The chalk texture is a bit thin and sharp, looking more like a digital brush than real chalk dust
• − The board lacks a frame, making it look a bit flat

Wan 2.6

• + Superb realistic chalk texture with dust particles and smudges
• + Excellent central composition with a rustic wooden frame
• + Stylized elegant cursive for the header as requested

• − Handwriting style is slightly inconsistent between lines
• − The word 'APRIL' uses a stylized 'L' that is slightly less readable than Model A

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent cinematic lighting and composition with high-quality planet rendering.
• + High level of detail on the horse's fur and the astronaut's suit textures.
• + Consistent starfield and nebulae that feel grounded in the scene's color palette.

• − Failed the negative constraint; the astronaut is riding the horse instead of the horse riding the astronaut.

Wan 2.6

• + Dynamic lighting with dramatic god rays and vibrant nebula colors.
• + Impressive reflections on the astronaut's visor showing a starfield.
• + Clean, sharp rendering of the horse's mane and tack.

• − Failed the crucial negative constraint; depicts an astronaut riding a horse.
• − The dust at the bottom of the frame implies a ground surface, which detracts from the space setting.

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent photorealistic texture and cinematic lighting
• + Anthropomorphic hand-like paws realistically placed on steering wheel
• + Very clean composition and superior depth of field

• − The capybaras face is mostly in profile, losing some of the professional expression requested

Wan 2.6

• + Perfectly captures the bored, slightly annoyed expression of the businesswoman
• + Front-facing capybara with a very clear calm expression
• + Good adherence to color and clothing descriptions

• − The woman appears to be in the passenger seat rather than the back seat
• − Technical artifacts like rain falling inside the car and inconsistent scale
• − Distorted paw shapes on the steering wheel

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent typography with a professional, cinematic gothic font.
• + High-quality, realistic textures on the jack-o-lantern and tree bark.
• + Very clean and readable layout that feels like a polished invitation poster.

• − The 'scroll banner' is a bit plain and lacks the vintage parchment texture requested for that specific element.

Wan 2.6

• + Successfully incorporates the 'thorns' into the border as requested.
• + Good use of color contrast and glowing lighting effects on the ground.
• + Accurate text rendering for all requested fields.

• − The 'thorns' on the border look slightly artificial and pasted on.
• − The typography is less 'elegant' compared to Model A, with a more generic glitter texture.

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent graphic design and typography integration
• + Realistic grain textures on the rice
• + Highly polished, clean commercial aesthetic

• − The diorama base filled with loose rice is a bit of an unusual interpretation
• − Text layout is slightly offset to the right instead of perfectly centered

Wan 2.6

• + Perfect 45-degree isometric composition
• + Excellent interpretation of the diorama base and miniature style
• + Clean and clear typography with correct flag icon placement

• − The rice texture on the sushi is a bit repetitive/patterned compared to Model A
• − Minimal artistic flair in the light blue background

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent fur texture and realistic anatomy for all four animals.
• + Captures the 'tumbling' and playful energy accurately.
• + High resolution with beautiful dew drops on the vegetation.

• − The fox's face looks slightly more mature than a 'kit'.
• − The backlight is a bit intense, causing some hazy lens flare in the upper left.

Wan 2.6

• + Perfect implementation of 'god rays' and sunrise lighting.
• + Adorable, wide-eyed expressions on all animals that match the 'wholesome' request.
• + Very balanced composition with all animals facing the viewer.

• − The kitten has five prominent legs or paws visible, indicating a structural error.
• − The butterflies are less integrated into the scene's lighting compared to the animals.

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent typography with proper accented characters
• + Clean vector aesthetic suitable for a modern-vintage logo
• + Balanced centered composition

• − The 'Est. 1720' text is very small and lacks a distinct banner shape
• − Steam element is a bit stylized and disconnected

Wan 2.6

• + Strong vintage texture on the background adds character
• + The cloche dome has better shading and depth
• + Better integration of the 'Est. 1720' banner

• − Typography is slightly less refined than Model A
• − The 'Est. 1720' text is slightly skewed and harder to read

Recraft V4.1 Pro

• + Excellent adherence to the infographic structure, including all 6 requested steps.
• + Very clean typography and high-quality vector iconography that matches the requested flat style.
• + Strong adherence to the specific NASA-inspired color palette.

• − Step numbering contains a repeat (two '05' steps).
• − Literal interpretation of the prompt text led to the label 'Saturn Vicon' instead of 'Saturn V'.

Wan 2.6

• + Successfully used the requested color palette.
• + Includes the names of the three crew members as requested.

• − Failed to include any of the 6 infographic steps or icons requested in the prompt.
• − The image has a fabric-like texture that contradicts the 'clean vector' requirement.
• − Very poor composition with a large amount of empty space in the center.