Qwen Image Alibaba vs Recraft V4 Pro Recraft AI

Qwen Image

• + Excellent adherence to the 'plant behind the cube visible through glass' instruction
• + Clean and accurate glass reflections
• + Well-composed and aesthetically pleasing lighting

• − The cube has a mirror base that wasn't requested
• − The glass cube looks more like a frame or box with thick edges

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Very realistic material textures on the book and table
• + The blue sphere has high visual quality with beautiful internal light refraction

• − Failed the instruction for the plant to be behind the cube; it is placed to the side
• − The book does not sit naturally on the cube, appearing to float slightly on the left side

Qwen Image

• + Excellent handling of wet pavement reflections
• + Natural skin texture and anatomical accuracy in the hands
• + Clearer person-and-object interaction

• − Lacks the requested motion blur on the passing cars
• − Composition feels a bit sterile and clean for a 'candid' prompt

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Successfully captured motion blur from background vehicles
• + Strong cinematic atmosphere with high-contrast lighting
• + Gritty, realistic textures on the pavement and clothing

• − The bicycle structure is nonsensical and broken
• − The subject's hands are mangled and clipping into the bike frame
• − The rain effect looks like static noise rather than falling droplets

Qwen Image

• + Excellent vibrant lighting effects with realistic reflections on the armor.
• + Highly intricate engraving detail on the pauldrons and gorget.
• + Dynamic composition with clear spark bokeh and torchlight.

• − The scars look a bit like digital paint or 'ink' rather than healed skin tissue.
• − The beads appear somewhat floating or unnaturally attached to the hair.

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Substantially more realistic skin texture, dirt, and 'battle-worn' appearance.
• + Anatomically convincing hair braiding and bead integration.
• + The armor engraving feels more physical and grounded within the scene.

• − Lighting is a bit flatter and more muted compared to the prompt's request for warm torchlight reflections.
• − The depth of field is less shallow than requested, showing a lot of background detail.

Qwen Image

• + Strong aesthetic alignment with the 'modern minimalist' and 'vibrant accents' request.
• + Excellent grid layout that feels like a professional graphic design piece.
• + Creates a cohesive brand identity with bold sans-serif typography.

• − Text is largely illegible gibberish except for headers.
• − Food photography within the grid looks somewhat repetitive and artificial.

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Perfect text rendering with realistic dish names, descriptions, and prices.
• + High-quality, distinct food photography for every item.
• + Strict adherence to the specific sections requested (Appetizers, Pizza, Mains).

• − Layout is a bit traditional and lacks the 'graphic design' punch of Model A's grid.
• − White background feels slightly empty compared to the vibrant style requested.

Qwen Image

• + Excellent glowing neon text effect that integrates well with the theme.
• + Vibrant color palette with a strong sense of fiery atmosphere.
• + Good execution of the starburst element requested in the prompt.

• − The burger is not truly 'exploded' as much as it is surrounded by flying toppings.
• − The burger patty and bun look a bit more like a plastic toy than photorealistic food.

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Superior 'exploded' view where the core components are clearly separated vertically.
• + Highly photorealistic food textures, especially the meat patty and melting cheese.
• + Dynamic debris and embers enhance the sense of motion.

• − The fiery effect on the text feels like a basic overlay texture rather than a glow.
• − The starburst is a bit jagged and less polished than the rest of the image.

Qwen Image

• + Excellent chalk texture on the board surface
• + Dynamic handwriting with realistic slants and variations

• − Serious hallucination on the date, rendering '20026' instead of '2026'
• − Spelling error in 'Risotto' (spelled 'Risoto')

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Perfect text accuracy and spelling
• + Includes additional appropriate context like the café background and hanging chains

• − The text looks more like a digital font than natural chalk handwriting
• − Lowercase text at the bottom lacks the requested chalk texture

Qwen Image

• + Clean, high-quality rendering of the astronaut and horse.
• + Excellent composition with clear celestial bodies in the background.
• + Correctly follows the horse-riding instruction.

• − The mane and tail physics feel a bit static for space.
• − Slightly less 'surreal' than the other model, leaning more toward a standard collage look.

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Highly cinematic lighting and atmospheric effects.
• + Excellent use of debris/ice crystals to enhance the surreal feeling.
• + Very detailed textures on the spacesuit and horse's coat.

• − The astronaut's posture is slightly awkward.
• − The horse's back leg anatomy where it meets the ground/debris is a bit muddled.

Qwen Image

• + Excellent character placement and clarity of the passengers expression.
• + Very realistic capybara fur texture and cap fit.
• + Clean, professional-looking taxi interior details.

• − The paws on the steering wheel look anatomically incorrect, appearing more like primate hands.
• − The scale of the capybara head relative to the body looks slightly unnatural.

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Atmospheric rain effect and bokeh add to the New York night aesthetic.
• + The capybara's paws are rendered in a way that feels more consistent with the animal's actual anatomy.
• + Great use of 'NYC' text on the cap and rain droplets on the car surface.

• − The passenger in the back is quite dark and her expression is less clearly 'bored' than in Model A.
• − The perspective of the side mirror and dashboard is slightly warped.

Qwen Image

• + Perfectly captures the 'dark parchment' aesthetic requested in the prompt.
• + The gothic title font is very stylish and fits the vintage theme well.
• + Maintains a cohesive vintage illustration style throughout the entire composition.

• − Text rendering error in the main title ('Halle Party' instead of 'Halloween Party').
• − Overall image clarity is slightly softer compared to the competitor.

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Perfect text rendering for all requested information, including the specific date and location.
• + High visual clarity and impressive cinematic lighting on the jack-o-lantern.
• + Excellent border detail with realistic thorn and web textures.

• − Missed the 'dark parchment' texture requirement; it looks more like a modern digital poster.
• − The placement of the title text over the pumpkin makes it slightly harder to read.

Qwen Image

• + Excellent adherence to the '3D cartoon scene' style with soft, rounded textures.
• + Clean typography that fits the graphic design aesthetic.
• + Strong miniature diorama composition with a clear raised base.

• − The flag icon next to 'SUSHI' is slightly distorted.
• − The soft texture makes the rice look a bit like beads rather than realistic food textures.

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Highly realistic PBR materials, especially for the salmon and fish roe.
• + Creative interpretation of the diorama base as a square of salt or rice.
• + Precise text rendering and flag icon placement.

• − Missed the 'cartoon scene' style request in favor of realism.
• − The 'isometric' perspective is slightly lower than the requested 45 degrees.

Qwen Image

• + Excellent depiction of warm golden light and god rays
• + Extremely cute and clean character designs
• + Strong adherence to the 'tumbling together' part of the prompt

• − Has a slightly smoother, more 'AI-rendered' look rather than true photorealism
• − The butterflies look a bit like flat stickers against the background

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Higher level of photorealistic texture in the fur and environment
• + Excellent inclusion of dew sparkles on the wildflowers
• + Includes all four requested animals with more realistic proportions

• − The fox kit has a slightly awkward pose/blending near its back end
• − The bunny's eyes are a bit wide and startled compared to the others

Qwen Image

• + Strong minimalist vector style that is clean and professional.
• + Captures the warm brown and cream color palette perfectly.
• + Includes all requested elements: cloche, steam, and banner.

• − The text 'Florian' contains a distracting overlap error with the 'L' and secondary letters.
• − The cloche looks more like a flat icon than a vintage emblem.

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Excellent typography with beautiful classic curves and a correct accent mark.
• + The hand-drawn etching style fits the 'vintage' prompt more effectively than the flat style of Image A.
• + Technically superior text rendering with no overlapping distortions.

• − The 'Est. 1720' banner is quite small and lacks prominence compared to the main title.
• − The steam is rendered underneath the cloche, which looks slightly disconnected.

Qwen Image

• + Strong adherence to the NASA navy-blue color scheme
• + Artistically integrated the lunar surface into the composition

• − Numerous spelling errors including Tranor, Aldin, and CkEcem
• − Incorrect numbering and missing sequences in the steps
• − Rocket contains red flag sections that resemble the Chinese flag rather than NASA/USA

Recraft V4 Pro

• + Perfect text rendering with zero spelling errors in labels and descriptions
• + Followed all six requested steps in the correct chronological order
• + Clean, professional vector aesthetic that matches the infographic request perfectly

• − The color palette is slightly lighter than the classic NASA navy
• − Icons are somewhat small relative to the page size