Qwen Image Edit 2509 Alibaba vs Wan 2.5 (Preview) Alibaba

Qwen Image Edit 2509

• + Excellent preservation of the car's aesthetic and orientation.
• + Convincing motion blur on the wheels and road.
• + The subject's hair shows natural wind interaction with the environment.

• − The driver's face lacks detail and doesn't clearly resemble the source person.
• − Minor lighting inconsistencies on the car hood compared to the sunset.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Successfully identifies and integrates the specific person from the source image into the driver's seat.
• + The background environment feels very high-quality and geographically appropriate for California.
• + Great preservation of the car's design and reflections.

• − The man is wearing a scarf, which was in the source image but looks slightly unnatural for a sunny coastal drive.
• − The car's shadow on the road is a bit soft given the harsh daylight.

Qwen Image Edit 2509

• + Successfully applied the full outfit, including pants and shoes, by adjusting the camera framing.
• + Preserved the unique vitiligo patterns on the forehead and face of the person in Image 1.
• + Incorporated requested accessories like the ring and watch from Image 2.

• − Significantly changed the person's face structure and facial hair towards the person in Image 2.
• − Poor quality and warped details around the hands and eyes.
• − Changed the person's pose entirely to match Image 2's pose.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Excellent visual quality and high-resolution rendering.
• + Seamlessly integrated the coat and scarf onto the person's torso while maintaining the background.
• + Correctly matched the watch accessory from Image 2.

• − Completely replaced the person's head and face with the man from Image 2, ignoring the instruction to keep Image 1's face unchanged.
• − Failed to include the bottom half of the outfit (jeans and shoes) by cropping the original composition.
• − The person's vitiligo is entirely removed.

Qwen Image Edit 2509

• + Excellent preservation of the original facial features and lighting.
• + Hair texture is sharp and matches the lighting direction of the scene.
• + Seamless integration at the forehead and ears.

• − The hair volume is slightly exaggerated, giving a somewhat 'wig-like' silhouette.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Realistic hair density and natural flow.
• + Successfully preserves the background and clothing of the source image.

• − Subtly alters the person's face, specifically narrowing the eyes and changing the bridge of the nose.
• − The hairline integration on the forehead is a bit blurry compared to Model A.

Qwen Image Edit 2509

• + Excellent preservation of the original pose, clothing, and composition.
• + Strong caricature style with exaggerated facial features that still resemble the subject.
• + Cleverly blends the news anchor desk with a hockey rink background.

• − The dog is very small and lacks the detail/character of the rest of the image.
• − Nonsensical text in the speech bubble and on the monitors.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Successfully incorporates all elements: news desk, dogs in jerseys, hockey stick, and TV screen.
• + Clean, professional-looking illustration style.
• + The dogs are well-rendered and central to the theme.

• − Fails to preserve the original composition and pose of the source image.
• − The caricature face loses much of the likeness of the original woman.

Qwen Image Edit 2509

• + Excellent adherence to the 'Studio Ghibli' art style with clean line work and vibrant, warm colors.
• + Faithfully preserves the character poses and clothing patterns from the source image.
• + Captures the facial expressions effectively in an anime style.

• − The color palette is slightly more saturated than the requested 'soft pastels'.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Successfully incorporates atmospheric Ghibli elements like floating leaves and soft, hazy lighting.
• + Preserves the composition and character identities exceptionally well.
• + Features a more muted, nostalgic color palette as requested.

• − The line work is a bit less defined compared to Model A.
• − The background is more washed out, losing some architectural detail from the source.

Qwen Image Edit 2509

• + Successfully added distinct flying leaves with variety in color and shape
• + Effectively altered the hair to show strong directional movement
• + Maintained the facial features and clothing details of the subject very well

• − The hair movement looks slightly artificial and stiff compared to the original flow
• − The addition of a fan-like tail on the dog is unnecessary and looks less realistic than the original

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + The hair blowing effect looks more natural and integrated with the subject's posture
• + Preserved the original dog's appearance more accurately than the competitor
• + Good preservation of the background and color palette

• − The leaves are very sparse and look like simple green dots rather than actual leaves
• − Less 'dynamic' overall as the movement in the scenery is quite subtle