Qwen Image 2512 Alibaba vs Vidu Q2 ShengShu Technology

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent soft lighting consistent with the prompt
• + High-quality textures on the red book and wooden table
• + Accurate glass reflections and refractive effects

• − The glass cube has a mirrored base which wasn't explicitly requested
• − The plant in the background is very blurry

Vidu Q2

• + Stronger visual coherence of the plant through the glass
• + Dynamic lighting and shadow patterns on the table
• + Includes detailed spine text on the book showing high resolution

• − The sphere is hovering slightly off the bottom surface
• − The lighting is more direct and harsh than the 'soft' request

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent skin texture and facial details
• + Accurately represents the 50mm lens and shallow depth of field requested
• + Balanced, cinematic composition that maintains a candid feel

Vidu Q2

• + Successfully captures the 'imperfect framing' prompt with a tight, candid angle
• + Strong portrayal of wet pavement reflections and light rain

• − Anatomical errors in the hands and excessive skin wrinkles make it look stylized
• − Physically impossible bicycle structure with overlapping parts and broken frames
• − Lack of background motion blur compared to Model A

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent depiction of skin texture, fine pores, and realistic scars.
• + Superior integration of warm torchlight reflections on the metal armor.
• + Adheres better to the 'close portrait' request with a compelling, detailed facial expression.

• − The bokeh sparks are a bit large and localized compared to a natural distribution.
• − Braid physics near the shoulders look slightly stiff.

Vidu Q2

• + Ornate engraving on the armor is very intricate and well-defined.
• + Cloth texture on the underlayer shows high fidelity and clear material definition.
• + Dynamic lighting creates a strong sense of volume and depth.

• − The facial skin appears a bit too smooth and clean for a 'battle-worn' character.
• − The composition is more of a medium shot than the requested 'close portrait'.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Features a clear grid layout of food photos as requested.
• + Organizes sections clearly with distinct headers and colorful markers.
• + Font choice is bold and legible for a menu header.

• − Contains significant spelling errors in headers like 'APPETIIZIZERS' and 'MEANS'.
• − Some food items in the grid look repetitive or lack distinct variety.

Vidu Q2

• + Captures a more playful, modern aesthetic with vibrant photographic accents.
• + Includes the specific 'Pizza' section mentioned in the prompt.
• + Has a high-quality visual gloss and a clean white background.

• − The text is highly garbled and unreadable across the entire image.
• − The grid layout is less structured and more organic than the requested grid.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent typography with a glowing fire texture integrated into the 'MAGIC BURGER' title.
• + High photorealistic detail in the food textures, especially the patty and seeds.
• + Effective use of dynamic particles and flying ingredients to create a sense of motion.

• − The 'LIMITED TIME ONLY' text lacks the glowing effect compared to the main title.

Vidu Q2

• + Strong fiery atmosphere that covers the entire background.
• + Successful integration of all requested text elements, including a bright starburst.

• − The currency symbol is incorrect, showing a distorted 'E' or Hash symbol instead of the requested Euro '€'.
• − The food rendering looks slightly more plastic/saturated and less photorealistic than Image A.
• − The 'LIMITED TIME ONLY' text is placed too close to the main title, causing visual clutter.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent text legibility and spelling throughout the entire board.
• + Successfully rendered a realistic chalk texture with natural-looking cursive variation.
• + Followed the prompt instructions carefully, completing the 'Brown Butter' item logically.

• − One minor spelling error in 'Risitto' (should be Risotto).
• − The handwriting looks a bit too clean and calculated for a hand-drawn board.

Vidu Q2

• + Captures a very authentic, messy chalk smudging and layering aesthetic.
• + Good variation in stroke weight and pressure that mimics real chalk well.

• − Severe spelling and literacy issues, with many words becoming nonsensical (e.g., 'Octopd wpiln').
• − The text layout becomes cluttered and overlapping toward the bottom.
• − Failed to maintain coherent prices and item names.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent photorealism in the space suit and horse textures.
• + High cinematic quality with realistic lighting and earth-horizon background.
• + Clear, sharp details on the astronaut's face and visor.

• − Failed the negative constraint; the astronaut is riding the horse, not the other way around.
• − The horse's anatomy is slightly distorted with a missing or warped hind leg area.

Vidu Q2

• + Vibrant colors and a very creative 'nebula' horse design.
• + Good adherence to the 'surreal' aesthetic requested in the prompt.
• + Ornate space suit design with consistent stylization.

• − Failed the crucial negative constraint; the astronaut is riding the horse as per the common trope.
• − The horse's legs are stylistically melted or indistinct at the hooves.
• − Lower level of realism compared to the cinematic request.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent central composition through the windshield.
• + The capybara's expression is perfectly calm and professional as requested.
• + Realistic bokeh and light reflections on the windshield.

• − The capybara's paws look slightly human-like or primate-like.
• − Only the top half of the taxi is visible.

Vidu Q2

• + Dynamic side-profile composition that shows more of the taxi's interior.
• + The capybara's anatomy (paws and head shape) is very accurate.
• + Captures the 'bored' expression of the businesswoman effectively.

• − Significant architectural artifact where the taxi's door frame and roof meet behind the driver.
• − The passenger is holding her phone in a slightly awkward way.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent typography with only one minor misspelling
• + Highly atmospheric cinematic lighting and composition
• + Strong adherence to the border and twisted tree elements

• − Spells Halloween as 'Hallowern'
• − Missing the dark parchment texture requested in the background

Vidu Q2

• + Successfully incorporated the dark parchment texture
• + Good use of the scroll banner element

• − Multiple significant spelling errors and gibberish text
• − Incorrect date (2025 instead of 2026) and time data
• − Visual composition feels cluttered and less polished than the competitor

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent 3D miniature diorama feel with a tangible raised base
• + Perfect text rendering and layout for the title elements
• + Superior material quality, especially the rice grains and fish textures

• − The square base is slightly rotated rather than being perfectly isometric in alignment

Vidu Q2

• + Clean, high-contrast text rendering
• + Good adherence to the solid light blue background requirement
• + Successful 45-degree isometric projection

• − The textures look overly plastic and lack the requested realistic PBR quality
• − The flag icon is floating awkwardly on a pole rather than being integrated as a UI element
• − Details on the sushi, such as the shrimp and the Gunkan maki, are a bit messy

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent anatomical details and fur texture on all animals
• + Perfect lighting with soft god rays and clear dew sparkles
• + Strong composition with a focused, wholesome family-portrait style

• − Static posing fails to capture the 'chasing' and 'tumbling' action requested
• − The scale of the butterflies is slightly too large compared to the animals

Vidu Q2

• + Successfully captures the dynamic 'chasing' and 'tumbling' movement
• + Rich, immersive environment with a high volume of wildflowers and butterflies
• + Excellent use of wide composition to show the full scale of the scene

• − Includes two puppies instead of the requested single golden retriever
• − The rabbit's anatomy is slightly distorted with a cat-like tail
• − Animals are less 'hyper-photorealistic' and look more like digital paintings

Qwen Image 2512

• + Perfect text rendering of the name and establishment date
• + Excellent vintage woodcut/vector aesthetic that fits the 'classic' theme
• + High visual clarity and professional composition

• − The detail level is slightly higher than 'minimalist', bordering on an illustrative badge style

Vidu Q2

• + Captures a cleaner minimalist vector style
• + Follows the color palette accurately

• − Significant spelling errors in the brand name ('Farmiin', 'Fopli20')
• − Poorly rendered steam that looks like a flame or icon artifact inside the dome
• − Awkward layout with repetitive text strings

Qwen Image 2512

• + Features highly detailed and accurate illustrations of the Saturn V and Lunar Module.
• + Adheres well to the requested navy, white, and muted red color palette.
• + Successfully captures a professional infographic aesthetic with a clear visual hierarchy.

• − Step numbering is repetitive and logically confused (two step 2s, two step 3s).
• − Text becomes garbled in the middle section (e.g., 'Translaurtcit').

Vidu Q2

• + Closer to a true flat-vector style with consistent line weights across icons.
• + Contains very few distracting gradients, maintaining a clean 'sticker' look.
• + Maintains a consistent layout for the steps.

• − Fails significantly on text rendering, including the main header ('ALFONCH').
• − Icon choices are less accurate to NASA history, using a generic toy-like rocket instead of a Saturn V.
• − Logic of the mission steps is disorganized and contains redundant icons.