Qwen Image 2512 Alibaba vs Recraft V4.1 Recraft AI

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent depiction of physics and reflections within the glass
• + Very high textural realism on the book and wooden table
• + Accurately represents the transparency of the cube with the plant behind it

• − The sphere is slightly large for the requested 'small' descriptor
• − The cube has visible seams that make it look like a plexiglass box rather than a solid glass object

Recraft V4.1

• + Beautifully clear glass material and smooth lighting
• + Strong composition with plenty of negative space
• + Accurate sphere color and appearance

• − The blue sphere is floating unnaturally without support
• − The book edges are slightly blurry compared to the rest of the scene

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent facial detail and natural skin texture
• + Correct implementation of reflections and wet pavement
• + Strong 50mm lens aesthetic with appropriate depth of field

• − The subject is posing and looking at the camera, which contradicts the 'candid' and 'repairing' prompt
• − Bicycle geometry has structural errors, particularly around the chain guard and handlebars

Recraft V4.1

• + Perfect adherence to the 'candid' and 'repairing' action
• + Realistic raindrops and moisture on the man's jacket
• + Stronger sense of cinematic atmosphere and motion blur

• − The man's hands are mangled and lack anatomical correctness
• − Face is largely obscured, making the 'elderly Japanese man' criteria harder to verify than in Image A

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent adherence to the 'beads in hair' prompt with colorful details.
• + Superior skin texture showing hyper-realistic pores and varied scarring.
• + Subtle and professional use of torchlight as a rim light source.

• − The torch flame in the background is a bit distracting in its shape.
• − The expression is slightly stiff compared to the cinematic feel of Model B.

Recraft V4.1

• + Highly cinematic composition and dynamic lighting.
• + Exceptional detail on the engraved armor patterns and cloth textures beneath.
• + More lifelike, emotive eyes with realistic moisture and light refraction.

• − The beads in the hair are less prominent and colorful than requested.
• − The scarring is slightly less varied across the face than in Model A.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent grid layout for food photography
• + Consistent visual style with vibrant color accents
• + Strong professional branding feel

• − Text is mostly gibberish or nonsensical characters
• − Category names have major spelling errors like 'APPETIIZIZERS'

Recraft V4.1

• + Perfect English text rendering and legible menu items
• + Clean, functional minimalist design that works as a real menu
• + Accurate representation of the requested food categories

• − Food photos are not arranged in a tight grid as requested
• − Visual composition feels slightly empty on the right-hand side

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent typography with a glowing, fiery 3D effect.
• + High-quality photorealistic rendering of the burger texture.
• + Dynamic composition with embers and debris creating a strong sense of motion.

• − The burger is less 'exploded' and more slightly separated than Model B.

Recraft V4.1

• + Perfect adherence to the 'exploded' request with wide separation of components.
• + Accurate text rendering for all requested strings.
• + Good integration of smoke and sparks in the background.

• − The price starburst looks like a flat clip-art sticker rather than a fiery integrated element.
• − The lettuce and patty textures appear slightly less appetizing/photorealistic than Model A.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent typography style with elegant cursive and creative layout.
• + Highly realistic board textures including chalk dust and erasure marks.
• + Very clear and legible text rendering across the entire menu.

• − Includes a spelling error in 'Risitto' (should be Risotto).
• − Handwriting looks slightly more like a digital brush than actual granular chalk.

Recraft V4.1

• + Captured the granular, dusty texture of real chalk perfectly.
• + Followed all spelling requirements correctly without typos.
• + Features authentic natural variations in letter size and spacing.

• − The 'cursive' requirement for the title is very loosely interpreted as print with some connections.
• − The compositional balance is slightly top-heavy compared to the other model.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent photorealism in the spacesuit and horse textures.
• + Clear, clean composition with the Earth in the background.
• + Follows the instruction to have the astronaut riding the horse.

• − The horse's anatomy is slightly glitched where the front legs meet the chest.
• − The scale of the astronaut relative to the horse feels slightly off.

Recraft V4.1

• + Very cinematic and surreal composition with asteroids and a nebula.
• + Dynamic lighting and atmospheric effects create a more epic feel.
• + Accurately places the astronaut on top of the horse as requested.

• − The horse's hind legs have anatomical issues with transparent or missing joints.
• − Lower overall clarity compared to Model A.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent front-facing composition that highlights the capybara's expression
• + High photographic detail on the capybara's fur and the taxi interior
• + Accurately depicts the bored, almost annoyed expression of the passenger

• − The paws on the steering wheel look slightly like human fingers or gloves
• − The crop is very tight, losing some of the Manhattan background context

Recraft V4.1

• + Natural side-profile composition that feels more cinematic and realistic
• + The capybara's paws look more anatomically correct for the animal
• + Better integration of the passenger within the vehicle cabin space

• − The capybara is not wearing the requested dark jacket
• − The capybara is slightly oversized for the driver's seat, pressing against the roof

Qwen Image 2512

• + Perfect text rendering with zero spelling errors
• + Excellent layout and composition with a clear visual hierarchy
• + Highly polished, clean digital art style with symmetrical borders

• − Includes a blatant spelling error in the main title ('Hallowern')
• − The background looks more like a modern digital painting than the requested 'vintage parchment'

Recraft V4.1

• + Captures the 'vintage parchment' and 'gothic' atmosphere much more effectively
• + Correctly spells the main title 'Halloween'
• + More intricate and moody background with the moon and weathered textures

• − The secondary scroll banner is very small and the text within it is slightly warped
• − The event details at the bottom are simple and less integrated into the design

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent 3D cartoon art style with vibrant colors and rich textures.
• + Includes a visually interesting diorama base with grass and garnish as requested.
• + Text is bold, stylized, and fits the miniature theme perfectly.

• − The 'JAPAN' text is slightly off-center compared to the rest of the composition.
• − The food items are a bit crowded on the plate.

Recraft V4.1

• + Cleanest execution of the isometric perspective and diorama base.
• + High-quality PBR-like materials, especially on the raw fish textures.
• + Perfectly centered typography and layout.

• − The 'SUSHI' text is quite thin and lacks the requested 'bold' characteristic.
• − Missed the small details of garnish like the white ginger (gari) seen in model A.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Features all four requested animals correctly.
• + High quality facial expressions and eye details.
• + Strong lighting effects with prominent god rays.

• − Static, posed composition rather than 'playfully chasing and tumbling'.
• − The animals appear somewhat fused together at the base.

Recraft V4.1

• + Excellent adherence to the 'playfully chasing' and 'tumbling' action requested.
• + Highly realistic fur texture and lighting integration.
• + Dynamic and natural composition that feels candid.

• − The fox's tail transition to the bottom right looks slightly detached.
• − One butterfly is less distinct against the god rays.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent typography execution with a high-quality hand-lettered feel.
• + Beautifully detailed illustration of the cloche with realistic steam.
• + Perfectly captures the requested 'warm brown and cream' color palette and subtle texture.

• − The design is quite complex and leans more towards an illustration than a 'minimalist' logo.

Recraft V4.1

• + Successfully adheres to the 'minimalist' aspect of the prompt.
• + Clean, professional vector style that would be easy to reproduce.
• + Correct inclusion of all prompt elements in a balanced layout.

• − The 'Est. 1720' text is slightly off-center within the banner.
• − The steam icon is very generic and lacks the charm requested by 'vintage'.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Includes more illustrative detail in the lunar module and planetary bodies.
• + Successfully captured the requested palette with good use of navy and orange-red tones.
• + The composition feels like a cohesive poster with a clear sense of environment.

• − Several spelling errors in the labels including 'Translaurtcoit' and 'Desceeint'.
• − The numbering is chaotic and repetitive, failing to follow a logical sequence.
• − Text from the prompt like 'Steps stop at landing' was mistakenly rendered as a subtitle.

Recraft V4.1

• + Excellent adherence to the clean, flat-vector infographic style requested.
• + Precise and legible typography with no spelling errors in the main headings.
• + Strict adherence to the requested NASA-inspired color palette.

• − Numbering error where step 4 is repeated and step 5 is skipped.
• − The iconography for the Lunar Module is very abstract and repetitive between steps 5 and 6.
• − Literal interpretation of the prompt led to including the prompt text 'Saturn Vicon' as a caption.