Qwen Image 2512 Alibaba vs Recraft V4 Recraft AI

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent adherence to lighting instructions with natural soft light from the left.
• + The glass cube has realistic reflections and refractions of the background plant.
• + The composition feels very natural and photorealistic.

• − The sphere inside appears to be floating or leaning against a side wall rather than resting on the bottom.
• − The book is slightly too large for the cube it sits on.

Recraft V4

• + The sphere is more central and features complex internal reflections.
• + High level of detail on the textures of the book pages and cover wear.

• − The sphere is levitating inside the cube, which defies physics without explanation.
• − The glass of the cube looks more like solid blocks of acrylic than a hollow glass container.
• − The lighting is somewhat flat compared to the specific 'window light' request.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent skin texture and facial details
• + Accurate 50mm lens compression and bokeh
• + Subtle but effective motion blur on passing vehicles

• − The man is posing/looking at the camera rather than actively repairing the bike
• − The bike geometry is nonsensical with the handlebars and seat facing opposite directions
• − Lack of visible rain droplets compared to Model B

Recraft V4

• + Stronger adherence to the 'repairing' action and 'candid' feel
• + Superior environmental effects with visible rain and vibrant reflections
• + Effective motion blur on the right side of the frame

• − The subject's face is obscured and less detailed
• − The bicycle setup is physically impossible (no front fork, wheel just floating)
• − The background pedestrians look a bit painterly or smudged

Qwen Image 2512

• + Exquisite lighting with a strong warm glow that highlights the facial textures and skin pores.
• + Extremely lifelike eyes with realistic reflections and depth.
• + Fine, high-resolution detail on the engraved metal gorget and leather straps.

• − The sparks in the background look a bit like digital artifacts rather than natural embers.

Recraft V4

• + Excellent character design matches the 'battle-worn' description well with realistic grime and scars.
• + Stronger costume design featuring more complex engraving across the entire suit of armor.
• + Better integration of the sparks into the environment.

• − The eyes feel slightly flat compared to Model A.
• − Vertical braids near the face appear somewhat thin and unnatural in their placement.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Strong composition with a cohesive grid of food photos
• + Clean use of vibrant accent colors that match the modern aesthetic
• + Faithful adherence to the section requirements (appetizers, pizza, etc.)

• − Text consists of gibberish characters and misspellings
• − Some food items in the photos look distorted or over-rendered

Recraft V4

• + Perfect English text rendering with logical menu items and pricing
• + Very clean, minimalist layout that looks like a real professional asset
• + Individual food photography is high quality and isolated cleanly

• − Does not follow the 'photos in grid' instruction, instead using isolated png-style images
• − Lacks the vibrant accents requested, opting for a very sparse white palette

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent typography with a glowing fire effect that perfectly matches the prompt.
• + Professional ad composition with balanced placement of text and product.
• + Highly detailed food textures, particularly the sear on the meat and the freshness of the vegetables.

• − The burger is slightly less 'exploded' than Model B, appearing more like a tall stack than a fully deconstructed motion shot.

Recraft V4

• + Stronger sense of motion with ingredients scattered at various angles.
• + Hyper-realistic bread texture and sauce drips create a very convincing photographic look.

• − The 'MAGIC BURGER' text is warped and lacks the requested fiery/glowing aesthetic.
• − The starburst for the price looks like a flat graphic that clashes with the photographic reality of the image.
• − Failed to apply the fiery/glowing effect to all text elements.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent legibility with elegant cursive styling.
• + Highly realistic chalk texture with dusty smudges on the board.
• + Large, well-centered composition that fills the frame.

• − Includes a spelling error ('Risitto' instead of 'Risotto').
• − The lettering looks slightly too clean and uniform for natural handwriting.

Recraft V4

• + Highly realistic handwriting with natural variations in letter size and baseline.
• + Perfect spelling on all menu items.
• + Authentic café environment in the background enhances the 'cozy' atmosphere requested.

• − The chalk texture is a bit grainy, making the smaller text at the bottom slightly harder to read.
• − Composition is a bit cluttered with the background elements compared to the clean board focus.

Qwen Image 2512

• + High resolution and clear lighting contrast
• + Realistic textures on the spacesuit and horse fur

• − Failed the negative constraint; the astronaut is riding the horse instead of the horse riding the astronaut
• − Lacks the 'surreal' quality requested, appearing as a standard composite

Recraft V4

• + Atmospheric, cinematic composition with good depth of field
• + Detailed environment with asteroids and planetary backdrop

• − Failed the negative constraint; the astronaut is riding the horse
• − The anatomy of the horse's back legs is slightly distorted

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent photorealism in various textures like fur, fabric, and skin.
• + Dynamic and engaging composition with a centered subject.
• + Clear, high-resolution rendering of the capybara's expression and accessories.

• − The passenger's expression looks slightly distressed rather than 'bored'.
• − The scale of the capybara relative to the car interior is slightly exaggerated.

Recraft V4

• + Perfectly captures the 'bored' and 'normal' atmosphere requested in the prompt.
• + Highly realistic taxi interior details including the upholstery and 'Metered Fare' sign.
• + Complex lighting effects with rain on the windows and city bokeh.

• − The capybara's head is clipping through the roof/visor area of the taxi.
• − The steering wheel appears to be on the right side, which is incorrect for a New York taxi.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent scroll banner for the subtitle text.
• + Very strong composition with clear, high-contrast text rendering.
• + Includes all requested border elements including webs and thorns.

• − Spelling error in the main title ('Hallowern').
• − Parchment texture is less evident compared to a digital illustration style.

Recraft V4

• + Perfect spelling for all requested text elements.
• + Beautiful painterly aesthetic with detailed fallen leaves and rain/mist effects.
• + Higher level of atmospheric detail in the background trees and bats.

• − Subtitle is on a plain white tag rather than a scroll banner.
• − Lacks the 'thorns' element in the border, focusing primarily on webs.

Qwen Image 2512

• + Perfectly captures the '3D cartoon miniature' aesthetic
• + Excellent typography that matches the art style
• + Clean, refined textures on the diorama base and sushi

• − The flag icon is integrated into the text line rather than being a separate element
• − Minor clipping on the wasabi shape

Recraft V4

• + Highly realistic PBR material textures on the fish
• + Accurate placement of the flag icon top-center
• + Crisp text and clean background

• − Missed the 'cartoon' style request, opting for a photorealistic look
• − The crystalline base is a bit busy compared to the requested 'small raised diorama'
• − Salmon texture on one nigiri looks slightly warped

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent fur texture and facial detail
• + Stronger adherence to the 'big expressive eyes' and '8K masterpiece' aesthetic
• + Clear and vibrant lighting with distinct god rays

• − Static composition that looks more like a portrait than 'tumbling and chasing'
• − Anatomy issues with the kitty's paw placement

Recraft V4

• + Successfully captures the action of 'playfully chasing' and 'tumbling'
• + Dynamic and immersive composition with butterflies in the foreground and background
• + Excellent handling of dew sparkles and environmental atmosphere

• − The fox's front right leg is unnaturally long and thin
• − Slightly less 'photorealistic' fur texture compared to Model A

Qwen Image 2512

• + Excellent typography including the correct accent on 'Caffè'
• + High level of detail on the cloche and banner
• + Perfectly captures the requested 'warm brown and cream' aesthetic with a subtle texture

• − The illustration is quite busy and borders on a vintage label rather than a minimalist logo

Recraft V4

• + Successfully achieves a more 'minimalist' vector emblem style
• + Clean and professional layout
• + Interprets the cloche and steam in a simplified, modern way

• − Incorrectly used a grave accent (è) instead of the correct accent for the brand name
• − Did not include the requested 'banner' for the Est. 1720 text
• − The stem/steam on the cloche is slightly off-center

Qwen Image 2512

• + High level of visual detail in the lunar module and Saturn V illustrations.
• + Good use of space and depth in the composition.

• − Numerous spelling errors in text (e.g., 'Translaurtcit', 'Desceeint').
• − Incorrect numbering and repeating of labels.
• − Included prompt text ('Steps stop at landing') literally in the image.

Recraft V4

• + Perfect text rendering with zero spelling errors.
• + Strict adherence to the 'flat-vector' style and icon consistency.
• + Correct and logical flow of the six requested steps.

• − The layout has a lot of empty white space which makes it feel slightly unfinished.
• − Vector icons are very simplistic compared to the more detailed imagery in Model A.