LongCat-Image Meituan vs Wan 2.5 (Preview) Alibaba

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent realism in the glass texture and reflections.
• + Accurate interpretation of 'small' regarding the blue sphere.
• + Clean and modern composition with high clarity.

• − The lighting is a bit flat compared to the other model.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Beautiful warm lighting and dynamic shadows.
• + Good realistic texture on the red book cover.
• + Creative use of atmospheric dust particles in the light.

• − The blue sphere's scale is quite large relative to the cube.
• − Minor clipping where the sphere appears to be touching the top of the glass cube.

LongCat-Image

• + Captures motion blur from passing cars very effectively.
• + Includes realistic rain splashes and wet pavement reflections.
• + Excellent mood and cinematic lighting that fits the street photography aesthetic.

• − Physical logic errors in the bicycle structure, showing an extra third wheel/frame component.
• − Visible rain streaks are overly uniform and look a bit like a filter.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Exceptional skin texture and anatomical detail on the man's hands and face.
• + The bicycle structure is much more coherent and realistic.
• + Very soft, natural depth of field that feels professional.

• − Misses the 'motion blur from passing cars' requirement almost entirely.
• − The lighting is a bit flat compared to the requested cinematic look.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent rendition of ornate engraved plate armor with high-quality metallic reflections.
• + Very colorful and detailed beads in the hair braids, effectively meeting the prompt.
• + Strong bokeh effect and lighting that creates a heroic, cinematic atmosphere.

• − The facial scars look a bit like flat textures or stickers rather than physical wounds.
• − The facial hair and skin texture lack the micro-detail found in the competitor.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Incredible skin texture and facial realism, with lifelike eyes and convincing dirt smudges.
• + Highly detailed texture on the tattered cloth and leather straps, appearing very tactile.
• + Excellent hair braiding with silver-toned beads integrated naturally into the style.

• − Lower lighting contrast on the armor compared to Model A, making the 'battle-worn' aspect feel more like dirt than metal fatigue.
• − The secondary hair braid on the left side appears to merge into the background or shoulder awkwardly.

LongCat-Image

• + Includes a wider variety of realistic food photography styles
• + Uses vibrant color blocking to define sections

• − Lacks the requested minimalist design aesthetic
• − Text is extremely garbled and messy compared to the competitor
• − Layout feels cramped and lacks white space

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Perfect adherence to the minimalist design requested
• + Clean grid layout with excellent use of white space
• + Captions and headings are much more legible and logically placed

• − Food photos are more repetitive and look somewhat synthetic
• − Limited text in the side column makes it look like a placeholder

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent typography with a professional 3D liquid-metal and fire effect.
• + High-quality photorealistic rendering of the burger textures, especially the bun and meat.
• + Strict adherence to the starburst and text placement requirements.

• − Fails to follow the 'exploded burger' instruction, showing a mostly assembled burger instead.
• − The background fire and coals look a bit static compared to the dynamic request.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Perfectly captures the 'exploded' view with components suspended in mid-air.
• + Highly dynamic composition with sauce droplets and floating ingredients enhancing the sense of motion.
• + Excellent integration of the fiery glowing effect on the text and starburst.

• − The 'MAGIC BURGER' text has a dripping effect that looks slightly more like cheese/honey than fire.
• − The bottom bun's angle is a bit awkward relative to the other ingredients.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent chalk texture including realistic dust and smudges at the bottom of the board.
• + Strong cafe background bokeh and warm lighting.

• − Text rendering is mostly gibberish with severe spelling errors.
• − Failed to follow the specific menu items requested in the prompt.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Perfect text rendering with near-flawless spelling of all complex menu items.
• + Consistent and attractive handwritten chalk style that feels authentic.
• + Followed all instructions, including the specific date and price points.

• − Slight repetition at the end of the menu where it lists the cookies twice.
• − The perspective is slightly angled rather than a straight-on shot.

LongCat-Image

• + Successfully placed the horse on top of the astronaut as requested by the specific reversal prompt.
• + High degree of surrealism in the juxtaposition of figures.
• + Clear and consistent lighting on the lunar surface environment.

• − Anatomical issues with the horse's legs, particularly the extra joint appearing in the back leg.
• − Low-quality rendering of secondary elements like planes and satellites.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Excellent visual quality and resolution.
• + Superior composition with a cinematic sense of movement and depth.
• + Highly detailed rendering of the astronaut suit and horse's muscles.

• − Failed the negative constraint; the astronaut is riding the horse instead of the horse riding the astronaut.
• − The scene is more conventional than the surreal concept requested.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent texture on the capybara's fur
• + Sharp, clear focus on the passenger characters
• + Vibrant colors and high-quality lens flare effects

• − The capybara only has one paw on the steering wheel despite the prompt request
• − The composition feels slightly crowded with two passengers instead of one
• − The capybara's paw looks more like a human hand with claws

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Perfect adherence to 'both front paws on the steering wheel'
• + Captures the bored, unaware expression of the passenger perfectly
• + Great atmospheric lighting and rain effects on the car exterior

• − The capybara's face is a bit symmetrical and less expressive than Model A
• − The steering wheel scale looks slightly off compared to the driver

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent typography style for the main title
• + Includes the thorn and web border as requested
• + Cinematic lighting on the pumpkin

• − Significant spelling errors in the bottom event details
• − The torn parchment layer is a bit distracting from the background elements
• − The scroll banner is small and lacks detail

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Perfect text rendering for both titles and event details
• + Superior visual quality and artistic composition
• + Beautifully integrated jack-o-lantern and twisted tree elements

• − The thorns are slightly less prominent compared to the spider webs
• − Slightly less 'parchment' texture on the paper compared to the other model

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent text rendering and alignment of both 'JAPAN' and 'SUSHI'.
• + Accurate representation of the requested flag icon.
• + Higher complexity in the 3D model with realistic textures for the rice and fish.

• − The perspective is slightly lower than the requested 45° isometric angle.
• − The base feels more like a standard wooden tray than a specific diorama base.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Perfectly captures the 45° top-down isometric perspective.
• + Very clean, minimal diorama base as requested.
• + Lighting is soft and aesthetically pleasing, enhancing the cartoon 3D look.

• − The flag icon is less integrated and looks like a simple flat graphic.
• − Text is slightly less refined compared to the first model.

LongCat-Image

• + Strong composition with a clear, happy focal point on the golden retriever.
• + Rich golden sunrise lighting and prominent god rays that enhance the mood.
• + Vibrant colors in the wildflowers.

• − Failed to generate a bunny, instead creating a 'cat-bunny' hybrid with elongated ears.
• − The fox's tail transition looks anatomicaly awkward.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Successfully included all four requested animals (dog, cat, bunny, fox) as distinct species.
• + Better sense of movement and 'playful chasing' through varied poses.
• + Excellent rendering of dew sparkles and fine fur textures.

• − The fox has strangely glowing, human-like blue eyes which looks unnatural.
• − The butterflies appear somewhat flat compared to the surrounding 3D environment.

LongCat-Image

• + Strong hand-drawn woodcut aesthetic
• + Highly detailed line work on the banner and steam
• + Good application of the requested subtle texture on the background

• − Text is repetitive and messy with 'Caffè' appearing twice
• − Styling of the top 'Caffè' is distorted and difficult to read
• − Composition is a bit cluttered compared to a minimalist logo

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Excellent vector emblem style with clean lines
• + Perfect spelling and typography layout
• + Professional composition that feels like a real commercial logo

• − The 'steam' is a bit small relative to the cloche
• − Slightly less 'subtle' texture on the edges, appearing more like crumpled paper

LongCat-Image

• + Clean vector illustration style.
• + Follows the specified NASA-inspired color palette effectively.

• − Fails to follow the requested 6-step sequence.
• − Text and typography are garbled and illegible.
• − Logical flow of the infographic is poor.

Wan 2.5 (Preview)

• + Successfully includes almost all requested steps with legible labels.
• + Highly accurate text rendering for the astronaut names.
• + Professional layout with a clear hierarchical flow.

• − The 'Saturn V' icon looks more like a shuttle mashup than a rocket.
• − The trajectory lines for 'Translunar' and 'Lunar Orbit' are slightly messy/overlapping.