LongCat-Image Meituan vs Recraft V4.1 Recraft AI

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent adherence to lighting instructions with a clear left-side window light source.
• + Realistic depiction of glass thickness and internal reflections.
• + Natural plant placement that creates depth.

• − The glass cube has an open top rather than being a solid cube, though the book rests on the edges.

Recraft V4.1

• + Features a solid glass cube as requested.
• + Very high texture quality on the wooden table and book cover.

• − The blue sphere appears to be floating unnaturally in the center of the cube.
• − The sphere has a strange horizontal line through it, making it look like it's half-filled with liquid.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent handling of environment lighting and wet pavement reflections
• + Includes detailed background elements like Japanese shopfronts and traffic
• + Maintains clear focus on the subject in a wider scene

• − The bicycle structure is physically impossible with overlapping wheels/frames
• − Rain effect looks slightly artificial and uniform
• − Hand interaction with the bicycle lacks precision

Recraft V4.1

• + Successfully captures the requested 'imperfect framing' and cinematic feel
• + Realistic skin texture and garment dampness from the rain
• + Conveys a stronger sense of motion in the background vehicles

• − The composition is very tight, crop cuts off a significant portion of the subject and bike
• − Visual clarity is slightly lower due to heavy grain and rain effects
• − The red of the bicycle is less prominent than requested

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent engraving details on the chest plate
• + Vibrant warm lighting and high contrast
• + Clear inclusion of beads in the braids

• − Facial scars look more like fresh wounds or paint
• − Composition is very static and centered

Recraft V4.1

• + Naturalistic and lifelike eyes with intricate iris detail
• + Superb texture on the skin and realistic scarring
• + Dynamic close portrait composition that feels more intimate

• − The beads in the hair are less distinct than requested
• − Armor engraving is slightly more muted compared to the other model

LongCat-Image

• + Successfully integrates images into a grid-like layout.
• + Captures the vibrant, high-energy aesthetic requested.

• − Text consists of illegible gibberish characters.
• − Visual artifacts appear around the text and borders.

Recraft V4.1

• + Excellent text rendering with clear, legible English.
• + Strict adherence to all structural requirements including specific sections.

• − The layout is slightly sparse with significant white space on the right.
• − Image alignment within the vertical grid is somewhat inconsistent.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent typography with a professional glowing neon/fiery effect.
• + Clean, commercial-grade photorealistic textures on the food components.
• + Dynamic composition with embers and a strong sense of a fiery grill environment.

• − Failed to provide an 'exploded' burger, showing an assembled burger instead.
• − The starburst element looks a bit like a generic sticker compared to the rest of the high-quality art.

Recraft V4.1

• + Successfully followed the instruction for an 'exploded' view with suspended components.
• + High-quality flaming text effect for the main title that integrates well with the theme.
• + Great sense of motion and smoke, enhancing the 'magic' aspect of the prompt.

• − The starburst price tag is very basic and lacks the requested 'fiery, glowing effect'.
• − The composition feels a bit bottom-heavy with most ingredients drifting downward/left.

LongCat-Image

• + Captures a nice café background with a realistic chalkboard frame and eraser dust.
• + The handwriting has a strong chalk-like texture.

• − Text consists and almost entirely of gibberish and misspellings like 'ToAYS GtAYS'.
• − Fails to follow the specific menu items listed in the prompt.
• − The layout is cluttered and the cursive requirement for the header is not met.

Recraft V4.1

• + Excellent prompt adherence with nearly perfect spelling of all complex menu items.
• + Realistic chalk texture with natural variations in letter size and authentic strokes.
• + Completed the truncated prompt intelligently by finishing the final item as 'Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies'.

• − The frame of the chalkboard is cut off at the top and edges.
• − The header is in print rather than the requested elegant cursive style.

LongCat-Image

• + Strong composition with a clear focal point
• + Technically clean image with high resolution and minimal artifacts
• + Good variety of space-themed elements like planets and lunar modules

• − Failed the negative constraint: the astronaut is riding the horse instead of the horse being on top
• − The horse having five legs is a significant biological artifact

Recraft V4.1

• + Atmospheric lighting and cinematic nebular effects
• + Dynamic pose for both the horse and the astronaut
• + Rich texture on the asteroids and space suit

• − Failed the negative constraint: the astronaut is riding the horse instead of the horse being on top
• − The horse's legs and hooves are muddled and lack clear structure

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent fur texture and sharp character details
• + Strong colors that suggest the vibrant night atmosphere of NYC
• + Good adherence to the requested clothing like the dark jacket and white shirt

• − The passenger's hand holding the phone has anatomical issues
• − The capybara's hand/paw on the steering wheel looks like a human-animal hybrid with long nails
• − Includes two passengers instead of one

Recraft V4.1

• + Perfect adherence to the single passenger request with a bored expression
• + The capybara's paws look more like natural paws resting on the wheel
• + The yellow cap and interior lighting look very authentic and cinematic

• − Missing the dark jacket on the capybara, it appears to be shirtless/fur-only
• − The lighting on the passenger is a bit flat compared to the driver
• − Lower overall sharpness in the background compared to Model A

LongCat-Image

• + Successfully included almost all requested text elements.
• + Clean and legible layout for an invitation.
• + Bright, cinematic lighting on the central jack-o-lantern.

• − The location text is misspelled as 'The Armiees'.
• − The composition feels a bit like a digital collage rather than a weathered vintage poster.
• − Includes redundant and nonsensical text strings like '3uulie' and '7um:'.

Recraft V4.1

• + Excellent atmospheric quality and moody, vintage gothic aesthetic.
• + Perfect text accuracy for all details, including the specific location.
• + Superior artistic composition with more detailed twisted trees and a seamless border.

• − The elegant gothic title text is slightly harder to read due to its extreme stylization.
• − The scroll banner is somewhat small relative to the other elements.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent 3D miniature aesthetic with soft, clay-like textures.
• + Perfect text layout and font choice that feels integrated into the design.
• + Excellent use of the 45-degree isometric perspective.

• − The rice texture is slightly stylized and chunky rather than realistic PBR.

Recraft V4.1

• + High-quality PBR materials, especially on the fish and diorama base.
• + Clean, professional composition with realistic shadows.
• + Accurate sushi anatomy, including the shrimp tail.

• − The text is placed at the very top edge, feeling a bit cramped compared to Model A.
• − The miniature 'cartoon' feel is less pronounced than in Model A.

LongCat-Image

• + Strong lighting effects with prominent god rays
• + Vibrant colors and clear, large butterflies

• − Anatomical failure where the kitten has long rabbit ears
• − Missed a subject entirely, featuring only three animals instead of four
• − Floating bubble-like artifacts look unnatural

Recraft V4.1

• + Successfully included all four requested animals (dog, cat, bunny, fox)
• + Excellent dynamic posing that captures the 'tumbling' and 'chasing' aspects of the prompt
• + More realistic fur textures and higher overall photorealism

• − The fox kit's proportions are slightly awkward relative to its paws

LongCat-Image

• + Successfully captured the requested banner element for the establishment date.
• + Effective use of warm brown tones and vintage texture in the background.
• + Strong illustrative style that feels hand-drawn and retro.

• − The text is cluttered and repetitive, including 'Caffè' multiple times at the top.
• − The cloche is overwhelmed by the typography rather than acting as a clean icon.

Recraft V4.1

• + Excellent minimalist vector execution that looks like a professional logo.
• + Perfect typography and layout with a clear, readable design.
• + High fidelity with no artifacts or repetitive text errors.

• − The banner for 'Est. 1720' is very small and lacks the 'vintage banner' character of the other model.
• − The background is very clean, missing the 'subtle texture' requested in the prompt.

LongCat-Image

• + Strong composition for a physical poster layout
• + Illustrative style is consistent across the two panels

• − Failed to follow the requested 6-step sequence
• − Text is largely gibberish and unreadable
• − Icons look more like generic clip-art than a modern flat-vector infographic

Recraft V4.1

• + Excellent adherence to the 6-step sequence and specific icons requested
• + High-quality text rendering and clear, modern typography
• + Perfectly followed the flat-vector style and NASA-inspired color palette

• − Duplicate numbering labels (two number 04s) on the bottom row
• − The lunar landing icon is identical to the descent icon rather than showing it on the surface