LongCat-Image Meituan vs Recraft V4 Recraft AI

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent adherence to lighting instructions with a clear source from the left.
• + The glass cube and blue sphere exhibit realistic transparency and reflections.
• + Clean, modern composition with vibrant colors.

• − The glass cube has a mirrored base inside that wasn't requested, making it look more like a display case.

Recraft V4

• + Texture of the wooden table and red book is highly realistic and detailed.
• + The plant is positioned perfectly behind the cube as requested.
• + The glass cube has a nice solid, refractive quality.

• − The blue sphere appears to be floating mid-air inside the cube, which defies gravity in a way not specified.
• − The lighting feels a bit more diffuse and less directional than LongCat-Image.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent adherence to the 'imperfect framing' prompt with the pole in the foreground.
• + Strong atmospheric lighting and reflections on the wet pavement.
• + Realistic posture and expression for the subject.

• − Physical deformity in the bicycle, which has three wheels and broken geometry.
• − The man's hands are mangled and poorly rendered.
• − Rain streaks look somewhat vertical and artificial compared to the environment.

Recraft V4

• + Highly realistic skin texture and apparel for the subject.
• + Better execution of motion blur from passing cars.
• + Superior bicycle anatomy and realistic rain integration.

• − The 'imperfect framing' is less pronounced than requested.
• − Missing some of the red color on the bicycle compared to Model A.

LongCat-Image

• + Vibrant color palette and dynamic lighting
• + Excellent adherence to the 'bead' requirement in the braids
• + Smooth, high-quality rendering of the engraved metal plates

• − The facial wounds look somewhat artificial and overly symmetrical
• − The character looks a bit too pristine and 'pretty' for a battle-worn description

Recraft V4

• + Captures a much more gritty and realistic 'battle-worn' aesthetic
• + Incredible skin texture and realistic, intense facial expression
• + Superior integration of dirt, grime, and environmental lighting on the armor

• − The braids are a bit messy and less distinct than in the other image
• − The 'beads' in the hair are less prominent

LongCat-Image

• + Contains vibrant colors and a complex graphic design
• + Follows the request for both a white background and vibrant accents

• − Text is completely illegible and gibberish
• − The layout is cluttered and does not feel professional
• − Food photos have varying lighting and styles that don't match well

Recraft V4

• + Perfect text rendering with coherent item names and descriptions
• + Professional, clean, and modern minimalist layout
• + High-quality, consistent food photography in a neat grid

• − Lacks the 'vibrant accents' requested, opting for a very sparse color palette

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent typography with high-quality glowing effects and clear hierarchy.
• + Very polished, commercial-grade lighting and vibrant colors.
• + Strong adherence to the fiery background and starburst element requirements.

• − Failed the 'exploded burger' requirement; the burger is mostly assembled rather than suspended in mid-air components.
• − The sauce rendering looks slightly like plastic rather than food.

Recraft V4

• + Successfully captured the 'exploded' aspect with all components clearly separated and suspended.
• + Realistic food texture and photorealistic lighting on the individual ingredients.
• + Good integration of the white sauce drips and crumbs which add to the sense of motion.

• − The background lacks the 'fiery' intensity requested, looking more like simple sparks.
• − The placement of the starburst is awkward and overlaps the bottom bun.
• − The fire effect on the text is less impactful compared to Model A.

LongCat-Image

• + The handwriting style has a thick, authentic chalk texture.
• + The overall composition feels very balanced and fits themes of a cozy cafe.

• − The text is highly illegible with numerous spelling errors and garbled words.
• − The handwriting style is more of a blocky cursive rather than the elegant cursive requested.

Recraft V4

• + Excellent text rendering with near-perfect spelling of the complex prompt requirements.
• + Includes creative chalk illustrations for each menu item that enhance the cafe aesthetic.
• + The chalk smudge textures on the background look very realistic.

• − The handwriting is a bit too uniform, bordering on looking like a digital font despite the chalk texture.
• − The text size is quite small relative to the board size compared to a real menu board.

LongCat-Image

• + Clear and vibrant lighting
• + Highly detailed rendering of the astronaut suit

• − Completely failed the prompt logic of placement, putting the astronaut on top
• − Anatomical issues with the horse's front legs and hoof placement
• − Incoherent background elements like the floating airplanes

Recraft V4

• + Atmospheric and cinematic lighting composition
• + Strong texture work on the rocks and the horse's coat

• − Failed the specific 'horse on top' instruction
• − The astronaut's legs appear somewhat fused with the horse's back

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent fur texture rendering on the capybara.
• + High contrast and vibrant lighting that feels like a busy city street.

• − The capybara's paw is morphing unnaturally through the steering wheel.
• − There are two passengers instead of the requested single businesswoman.

Recraft V4

• + Perfect adherence to the prompt including all subjects and the specific bored expression.
• + Much more realistic integration of the animal's paws interacting with the steering wheel.
• + Authentically photorealistic lighting and rain texture on the glass.

• − The fur texture is slightly softer and less defined than Model A.

LongCat-Image

• + Strong parchment effect and thorn border adherence
• + Clean, readable main title text
• + Excellent lighting on the central jack-o-lantern

• − Failed to correctly render the location 'The Arches', instead writing 'The Armiees'
• − The combination of the parchment overlay on a separate background feels a bit like a scrapbook collage
• − Bottom text is cluttered and includes messy artifacts

Recraft V4

• + Perfect text accuracy including the specific location
• + Sophisticated gothic atmosphere with coherent background elements
• + Highly detailed cobweb and thorn border execution

• − Banner text is very small and lacks the 'scroll' aesthetic requested
• − Jack-o-lantern texture is slightly more realistic/messy than 'cinematic polished'

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent 3D cartoon aesthetic with soft, high-quality textures
• + Strong typographic placement following the layout instructions
• + Appealing use of color and lighting for a miniature diorama effect

• − The flag icon is integrated oddly next to the text rather than as a separate element
• − The rice grain texture is slightly stylized/repetitive

Recraft V4

• + Clean typography and precise placement of the flag icon
• + Realistic PBR materials on the fish and ice base
• + Very sharp and clear render quality

• − Lost the 'cartoon' aspect of the prompt, leaning too far into realism
• − The ice base feels a bit visually noisy compared to the 'minimalist' request
• − The sushi arrangement is a bit scattered on the plate

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent god ray and lighting effects
• + Very clean, high-saturation color palette
• + High resolution on the central puppy

• − Failed to generate a bunny, instead creating a 'cabunny' hybrid with a kitten body and bunny ears
• − Missing the 'chasing' and 'tumbling' action from the prompt
• − Butterflies appear static and disconnected from the scene

Recraft V4

• + Successfully included all four distinct animals (puppy, kitten, bunny, fox)
• + Captured the dynamic 'tumbling' and 'chasing' motion requested
• + Beautiful integration of butterflies and dew sparkles throughout the meadow

• − The fox's anatomy is slightly elongated in its running pose
• − Overall contrast is a bit softer than the first image

LongCat-Image

• + Strong illustration detail on the lunar module
• + Vibrant colors that pop against the navy background

• − Nonsensical text rendering for all labels
• − Failed to follow the specific 6-step chronological sequence
• − Icons are inconsistent in style and scale

Recraft V4

• + Perfect adherence to the 6-step infographic structure
• + Professional typography with correct spellings for all mission phases and crew
• + Clean, consistent vector iconography that matches the requested flat style

• − Composition has a large amount of white space that feels slightly empty
• − The Saturn V rocket silhouette is very simplified compared to other icons