LongCat-Image Meituan vs Qwen Image Alibaba

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent photographic quality with realistic glass caustics and reflections.
• + Strong adherence to all spatial instructions and lighting direction.
• + The plant is clearly visible through the glass cube as requested.

• − The glass cube walls appear slightly inconsistent in thickness at the corners.

Qwen Image

• + Satisfies all prompt requirements including object placement and Lighting.
• + Clean composition with a nice shallow depth of field.

• − The glass rendering is less realistic, appearing more like a mirror on the bottom surface.
• − Perspective of the cube is slightly skewed, particularly the vertical corner lines.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent atmospheric lighting with vibrant red color pops and high-contrast reflections.
• + Captures the requested 'motion blur' on passing cars very effectively.
• + Cinematic framing and a more dynamic composition with depth.

• − The bicycle structure is physically impossible, appearing to have three wheels or overlapping frames.
• − The subject's hands are mangled and fuse with the metal of the bike.

Qwen Image

• + More realistic and coherent bicycle geometry compared to Image A.
• + Good adherence to the 'candid' street photography style with natural skin tones.
• + Better depiction of the man's hands interacting with the seat/frame.

• − Failed to include 'motion blur' from passing cars as requested.
• − The lighting is somewhat flat and lacks the 'cinematic' quality found in the competing image.
• − The man's feet appear to be floating or poorly integrated into the wet pavement.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent depiction of ornate, high-shine plate armor with realistic thickness and engraving
• + Accurate focus and shallow depth of field as requested
• + Clean rendering of multiple braids with color-consistent beads

• − The 'scars' look more like fresh, deep puncture wounds or skin sores rather than faint battle scars
• − The subject's expression is somewhat passive for a 'battle-worn' warrior

Qwen Image

• + Stronger 'battle-worn' characterization with more realistic facial scarring and a gritty expression
• + High detail on the cross-over leather straps and underlayer textures
• + Dynamic lighting with the torch visible in the frame providing clear directionality

• − The sparks have a stylized, 'star-filter' look that feels less natural than standard bokeh
• − Some floating beads on the left side and anatomical awkwardness in the hair braiding

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent food photography quality with realistic textures
• + Good use of vibrant pink accents for a modern feel
• + Clear grid-based layout for images

• − Text rendering is completely garbled and illegible
• − Typography lacks the requested professional sans-serif feel
• − Sections are poorly defined and chaotic

Qwen Image

• + Stronger adherence to 'minimalist' prompt with clean lines
• + Readable category headings ('Appetizers/', 'Pizza/mains')
• + Consistent grid layout for food photography on the left

• − Food images look somewhat artificial/plastic compared to Model A
• − Large empty red square in the center of the grid serves no purpose
• − Repeated use of the same salad/pizza images reduces variety

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent typography with brilliant fire and glass effects
• + High-quality photorealistic rendering of the main burger
• + Great use of lighting and glowing embers

• − The burger is not truly 'exploded' as requested, but rather floating as a whole unit
• − Small artifacts in the starburst shape

Qwen Image

• + Better adherence to the 'exploded' prompt with components flying apart
• + Very dynamic composition and sense of motion
• + Good rendering of the fiery background

• − Typography is slightly less polished than Model A
• − Some ingredients in the air look like generic plastic chunks (e.g., the sauce blobs)

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent realistic chalk texture with dusty residue at the bottom
• + Realistic framing and lighting within a café setting

• − Text is largely illegible and contains numerous spelling errors
• − Failed to include the third specific menu item
• − Layout is confusing with prices separated from items by lines

Qwen Image

• + Text is highly legible and follows the prompt's specific menu items
• + Good composition with clear hierarchy between title and items
• + Successfully rendered the 'Brown Butter...' item that was cut off in the prompt

• − Year is incorrectly rendered as '20026'
• − Handwriting looks slightly more like a digital font than natural chalk variations
• − The chalk texture is very clean, missing some of the grittiness requested

LongCat-Image

• + Strong cinematic lighting and high-contrast color palette.
• + Includes interesting background elements like lunar landers and distant planes.
• + High level of detail on the astronaut suit and horse's mane.

• − Completely failed the semantic prompt to have the horse 'on top' of the astronaut.
• − Anatomical issues with the horse's legs, particularly the front right leg.

Qwen Image

• + Features a cleaner, more coherent composition with a large planetary backdrop.
• + Good anatomical consistency for the horse in a zero-gravity pose.
• + Accurate rendering of the astronaut's gear and equestrian tack.

• − Failed to follow the specific instruction to have the horse riding the astronaut.
• − The surreal elements are limited to the setting rather than the subjects.

LongCat-Image

• + Features a highly realistic fur texture for the capybara.
• + Includes the requested 'yellow taxi driver cap' specifically.
• + Captures the bored expression of the passengers well.

• − The capybara's paw looks more like a human hand with long claws.
• − The composition feels a bit cramped with the taxi light appearing inside the door frame.

Qwen Image

• + Excellent anatomical rendering of the capybara's paws on the steering wheel.
• + The lighting and depth of field provide a more cinematic feel.
• + Successfully places both paws on the steering wheel as requested.

• − The capybara is not wearing a shirt/jacket combination as clearly as the prompt suggested (looks more like a single unit jacket).
• − The passenger is looking away from her phone rather than at it.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent typography rendering for the main title and scroll text.
• + Great cinematic lighting on the central Jack-o'-lantern.
• + Very strong adherence to the 'border with webs and thorns' prompt requirement.

• − The event details at the bottom are poorly rendered with severe spelling hallucinations ('The Armiees').
• − The transition between the parchment and the central scene is a bit harsh.

Qwen Image

• + Excellent layout with a more atmospheric and integrated illustration.
• + Perfectly accurate event details at the bottom with clear legibility.
• + Sophisticated composition that balances the trees, pumpkin, and text well.

• − The main title text contains a typo ('Hallo Party' instead of 'Halloween Party').
• − The larger parchment background is slightly plain compared to the internal illustration.

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent rendering of PBR materials with realistic subsurface scattering on the fish.
• + Perfectly clean typography and a well-placed flag icon as requested.
• + High visual clarity and an appealing miniature aesthetic.

• − The raised base is a simple wooden board rather than a distinct diorama landscape.
• − The placement of the flag icon is slightly crowded next to the text.

Qwen Image

• + Accurately interprets the 'raised diorama base' with a multi-layered platform.
• + Great layout with the addition of chopsticks and a physical flag pole that adds to the scene.
• + Strong adherence to the isometric perspective and cartoon style.

• − The text 'JAPAN' has slightly irregular letter shapes and spacing.
• − The materials look more like plastic/clay and less like the requested 'realistic PBR' sushi textures.

LongCat-Image

• + Strong god rays and vibrant lighting
• + Clear, high-contrast details on the golden retriever

• − Major prompt failure: merged a cat and bunny into a 'cabunny' hybrid
• − Butterflies appear flat and poorly integrated
• − The fox has an anatomical issue with its front legs

Qwen Image

• + Successfully rendered all four requested animals as distinct species
• + Effective use of bokeh and dew sparkles in the foreground
• + Better sense of movement and interaction between the animals

• − The bunny's face is slightly blurry compared to the other animals
• − Background lighting is a bit softer, reducing the '8K masterpiece' sharpness slightly

LongCat-Image

• + Excellent typography with correct spelling and accented characters.
• + Complex and visually appealing engraving-style textures.
• + Perfect adherence to all requested elements including the cloche and banner.

• − The word 'Caffè' is repeated twice, which was not explicitly requested.
• − The 'Est. 1720' text is slightly skewed to fit the ribbon curve.

Qwen Image

• + Successfully achieves a clean, minimalist vector aesthetic.
• + Good color palette adhering to the warm brown and cream tones.

• − Major typographical errors with jumbled letters in 'Florian'.
• − The steam effect is very basic compared to the artistic request.
• − Missed the accent on 'Caffè' in the main text block.

LongCat-Image

• + Stronger vector aesthetic with classic comic-style line work
• + Balanced layout with clear sections and supporting icons
• + Adheres well to the muted red and navy color palette

• − Nonsense text rendering for all labels
• − Fails to follow the specific 6-step sequence outlined in the prompt
• − Rocket icon is more of a generic space shuttle than a Saturn V

Qwen Image

• + Attempts to follow the sequential numbering requested in the prompt
• + Text rendering is significantly more legible, correctly identifying names like Collins and Aldrin
• + Clean flat-vector style with professional-looking gradients

• − Includes instructional text '(Stop at landing)' as part of the visual header
• − Logical errors in labels (e.g., '1. Sarth Orbit' and '3. Lunar d'ólle (Earth Orbit)')
• − Mixed up the execution of the requested icons within the requested sequence