HiDream I1 Full HiDream AI vs Recraft V4 Recraft AI

HiDream I1 Full

• + Excellent depiction of soft window light with realistic highlights and shadows
• + Highly realistic glass textures and reflections
• + Warm, appealing color palette

• − The sphere appears to be floating mid-air inside the cube without clear physical support
• − The plant is somewhat blurred in the background

Recraft V4

• + Strong composition with centered elements
• + Detailed texture on the red book and wooden table
• + Accurate glass refraction of the plant behind it

• − The cube appears to be a solid block of glass rather than a hollow cube containing a sphere
• − The lighting feels a bit flat compared to the requested 'soft window light'

HiDream I1 Full

• + Excellent character detail and skin texture
• + Strong color contrast with the red bicycle and wet pavement
• + Consistent lighting and realistic reflections

• − The man appears to be sitting in mid-air/on the bicycle frame rather than standing or squatting to repair it
• − Failed to include the requested motion blur for passing cars
• − Bicycle anatomy is physically impossible in the center

Recraft V4

• + Successfully captured motion blur on passing cars
• + Excellent portrayal of light rain and atmospheric depth
• + Natural, awkward 'candid' pose that fits the prompt's repair context better

• − The glasses and face lose some detail compared to Model A
• − Front wheel is slightly disconnected from the bicycle frame
• − Lower texture resolution on the man's clothing

HiDream I1 Full

• + Exceptional sharpness and clarity in the facial features and eyes
• + Strong interpretation of 'ornate engraved plate armor' with high-contrast details
• + Vibrant use of warm torchlight and bokeh sparks

• − The scars appear somewhat stylized and less realistic compared to the skin texture
• − Strong digital sharpening makes it look slightly more like a 3D render than a photograph

Recraft V4

• + Extremely realistic skin texture, dirt, and lifelike scars
• + Excellent rendering of the cloth underlayer and leather straps with realistic wear
• + Natural and cinematic lighting that integrates better with the environment

• − The armor engraving is slightly more subtle than Model A's interpretation
• − The focus on the forehead seems a bit uneven compared to the rest of the face

HiDream I1 Full

• + Successfully follows the grid layout request
• + Maintains high-quality, realistic food photography textures

• − Text consists of gibberish characters
• − Shows only pizza photos even for the mains and appetizers sections
• − Layout feels cramped and lacks professional typography spacing

Recraft V4

• + Excellent text rendering with no spelling errors
• + Accurately represents distinct food items (appetizers, pizzas, mains) as requested
• + Clean, modern minimalist aesthetic with vibrant orange accents

• − The layout is a bit repetitive with the isolated product shots on white

HiDream I1 Full

• + Successfully rendered the date and title according to the prompt.
• + The chalk illustration of the coffee cup is high quality.
• + The chalk texture on the 'Today's Specials' text is very realistic.

• − Largely failed on the specific menu item text, rendering gibberish or unrelated words.
• − Text style looks more like a digital brush than actual handwriting in the smaller list.
• − Prices do not match the prompt's instructions.

Recraft V4

• + Excellent prompt adherence for all specific menu items and their associated prices.
• + Superior composition that places the chalkboard within a realistic, cozy café environment.
• + Text rendering is legible and maintains a consistent handwritten style throughout.

• − The title is not in 'elegant cursive' as requested, but rather a standard print style.
• − The font feels slightly 'cleaner' than natural chalk, though it includes smudging on the board.

HiDream I1 Full

• + Perfectly adheres to the core subject matter with a clear astronaut-on-horse composition.
• + High contrast and vibrant cinematic lighting against the Earth backdrop.
• + The horse and astronaut are rendered with sharp, clean details.

• − The horse's front-right leg has an unnatural anatomical bend at the hoof.
• − The background clouds look a bit more like a sky than high orbit space.

Recraft V4

• + Excellent atmospheric detail with dust, rocks, and planet textures.
• + Sophisticated, muted color palette that feels very cinematic.
• + Dynamic composition with the horse galloping through an asteroid field.

• − Fails the specific prompt instruction 'horse on top' as the astronaut is clearly the rider.
• − The astronaut's left leg appears to be missing or incorrectly merged into the horse's flank.

HiDream I1 Full

• + Excellent texture on the capybara's fur and the jacket
• + Clear and legible 'TAXI' text on the cap
• + Higher resolution and sharpness on the subjects

• − The passenger appears to be sitting in the front shotgun seat rather than the back seat
• − The capybara's hands look very human-like and distorted on the wheel

Recraft V4

• + Correct spatial arrangement with the passenger clearly in the back seat
• + More realistic cinematic lighting and atmosphere representing a rainy NYC night
• + Authentic capybara paws and more distinct New York skyline details

• − The passenger's face is slightly less detailed and looks more disconnected
• − Overall image has a grainier, film-like texture that makes it less sharp than Model A

HiDream I1 Full

• + Clean graphic design layout with a clear parchment background.
• + The central jack-o-lantern has a high-quality, illustrative glow.
• + Bold, legible main heading 'Halloween Party'.

• − Failed significantly on the event details text, producing gibberish like 'Yootmber'.
• − Missing 'The Arches, NYC' and '30.10.2026' entirely.
• − The overall look is more like a clip-art collage than a cinematic poster.

Recraft V4

• + Perfect adherence to detailed text, including the date, time, and location.
• + High visual quality with atmospheric lighting, rain effects, and detailed textures.
• + Complex composition that integrates the border, trees, and bats into a cohesive scene.

• − The 'scroll banner' item is more of a floating white tag than a traditional scroll.
• − The font size for the date and location is somewhat small compared to the artwork.

HiDream I1 Full

• + Excellent adherence to the '3D cartoon' and 'soft refined textures' style.
• + Clean, bold text rendering and perfect isometric perspective.
• + Strong 3D miniature aesthetic with a cohesive diorama base.

• − Missing the requested small flag icon.
• − The sushi rice looks a bit like uniform bubbles rather than grains.

Recraft V4

• + Successfully includes the small flag icon.
• + Excellent realistic PBR materials, especially the fish and rice texture.
• + Clean typography and accurate isometric positioning.

• − Fails to capture the 'cartoon scene' style, opting for a photorealistic look instead.
• − The crystalline diorama base is more cluttered than the requested 'minimal' base.

HiDream I1 Full

• + Successfully rendered the golden retriever, foxes, and kittens with vibrant colors.
• + Excellent warm lighting and bokeh effect in the background.
• + Characters have very cute, large expressive eyes as requested.

• − Failed to include the baby bunny entirely.
• − Animals are sitting statically rather than 'tumbling and chasing' as described in the prompt.
• − The fox has a slightly painterly, illustrated look rather than being hyper-photorealistic.

Recraft V4

• + Included all four requested animals: puppy, kitten, bunny, and fox.
• + Captured the action of the animals 'chasing' and 'tumbling' through the meadow.
• + Superior photorealism with visible dew sparkles and detailed god rays.

• − The bunny's anatomy is slightly awkward in its mid-air pose.
• − Composition is a bit crowded with many butterflies overlapping.

HiDream I1 Full

• + Clean vector aesthetic
• + Excellent execution of the banner element
• + Good adherence to the requested color palette

• − Failed to include the primary brand name 'Caffè Florian'
• − The steam visual inside the cloche is slightly generic

Recraft V4

• + Successfully included all requested text including the main brand name
• + Sophisticated typography that matches the vintage theme
• + Better interpretation of 'subtle texture' on the cloche

• − The 'Est. 1720' is in a semi-circle rather than a banner
• − The steam coming out of the closed cloche lid looks a bit thin

HiDream I1 Full

• + Strong visual aesthetic with a bold poster feel.
• + Follows the NASA color palette closely with navy and muted red.
• + Good central graphics and balance.

• − Failed the sequential flow of the 6 steps requested.
• − Text rendering includes hallucinations like '+ UNG' and '+ ICON'.
• − Includes a space shuttle/plane hybrid rather than the Saturn V or Lunar Module requested.

Recraft V4

• + Perfectly followed the logical sequence of all 6 requested steps.
• + Excellent text rendering and typography for an infographic.
• + Captures the flat-vector iconography style and NASA palette perfectly.

• − Composition is a bit sparse with significant empty white space.
• − Icons are quite small relative to the total canvas size.