GPT Image 1 Mini OpenAI vs Wan 2.7 Pro Alibaba

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent adherence to the 'soft window light from the left' instruction.
• + Very clean and minimalist composition with accurate depth of field.
• + Photorealistic textures on the wooden table and red book.

• − The glass cube is slightly open at the top rather than being a solid closed cube.
• − The green plant is quite blurred in the background, making it less distinct through the glass.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Highly detailed glass rendering including reflections on the base of the cube.
• + The plant is very clearly visible and positioned directly behind the cube as requested.
• + Beautifully aged texture on the wooden table.

• − The glass cube has illogical vertical panes within its structure.
• − The red book looks slightly distorted on the right side.

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent preservation of the subject's face, hair, and unique clothing from the source image.
• + Accurately places the specific car from the source image into a new environment.
• + Cinematic lighting and motion blur create a realistic sense of driving.

• − The car model is slightly modernized/altered from the source (different headlights).

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Successfully places the car on a coastal road with high visual quality.
• + Retains the exact car model and features from the source image.

• − Completely fails to include the man from the source image, replacing him with a generic figure.
• − The scale of the driver relative to the car seems a bit small.

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent skin texture and realistic depth of field
• + Accurate depiction of light rain and micro-reflections on surfaces
• + Great emotional depth and candid feel in the close-up composition

• − The bike anatomy is slightly illogical with the chain area
• − Lack of visible Japanese street context in the background

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Stronger adherence to the Japanese street environment setting
• + Full-body composition shows the entire red bicycle clearly
• + Excellent wet pavement reflections including the vehicle headlights

• − The man's scale relative to the bicycle is slightly too small
• − The face and hands have a slightly smooth, less detailed texture compared to the other model

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent warm lighting that authentically reflects off the armor
• + Highly cinematic shallow depth of field with great lens bokeh
• + Intricate and realistic engraving on the plate mail

• − Missed the prompt requirement for beads in the hair
• − The leather strap detail is less prominent and detailed than in Model B

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Perfectly adhered to the requirement for small beads in the braided hair
• + Exceptional texture and detail on the leather straps and buckles
• + Clearer depiction of 'battle-worn' scars and dirt on the skin

• − The lighting feels slightly more artificial and less moody than Model A
• − The armor's metal texture looks a bit more like polished steel rather than heavy plate

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Perfect text legibility for main headers
• + High-quality, clean food photography in a structured grid
• + Excellent adherence to the minimalist prompt

• − Lack of actual menu items/descriptions makes it look like a template rather than a finished menu
• − The layout feels a bit empty on the left side

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Complete, functional menu layout with descriptions and prices
• + Sophisticated professional aesthetic suitable for a real restaurant
• + Includes realistic branding elements like a QR code and address

• − Small body text contains significant 'lorem ipsum' style typos and gibberish
• − The grid layout is slightly less clear than Model A's simple alignment

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent photorealistic texture on the bun and patty.
• + The fiery glowing text effect is perfectly integrated into the dark atmosphere.
• + Strong sense of vertical composition and natural food physics.

• − The 'exploded' effect is a bit static compared to the dynamic scattering of elements.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Highly dynamic 'exploded' composition with many flying ingredients.
• + Excellent text rendering and layout for a commercial ad.
• + Captures the 'fiery' background prompt with more literal flaming elements and smoke.

• − The cheese looks somewhat artificial and flat compared to the other ingredients.
• − Some ingredients like the pickles and parsley were not explicitly requested but added.

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent chalk texture throughout the lettering
• + Very realistic and natural handwriting variations
• + Perfect text accuracy and spelling

• − The title is in print-style block letters rather than the requested elegant cursive
• − The background context of a 'cozy café' is barely visible beyond the board frame

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Beautiful 'cozy café' background with nice lighting and depth
• + Highly consistent font/handwriting style
• + Good composition with decorative flourishes

• − Repeated the phrase '& Herbs - $28' twice on the second item
• − The text looks more like a digital font overlay than real chalk on a board
• − Failed to render the title in cursive as requested

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Successfully transferred the person, sunglasses, scarf, and clothing from Image 2.
• + Matches the yellow background and red stool environment accurately.
• + Good facial recognition and resemblance to the character reference.

• − Failed to match the 'exact' complex pose, simplifying the leg cross into a basic step.
• − The left foot (on the stool) is anatomically distorted with too many toes.
• − Changed the character's expression slightly to a smirk instead of the neutral look requested.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Perfectly preserved the original background, pose, and composition from Image 1.

• − Completely failed to perform the edit, ignoring the character reference (Image 2) entirely.
• − Just returned a cropped/modified version of the source Image 1.

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent cinematic lighting and atmosphere
• + The horse's mane and tail exhibit realistic movement for a vacuum/low-gravity environment
• + High textural detail on the space suit and horse hide

• − The astronaut's hand placement on the reins is slightly awkward

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Bright, clear colors and sharp detail
• + Detailed background featuring multiple planets and the Earth's atmosphere

• − Composition feels less cinematic and more like a collage
• − The horse's legs and hooves appear somewhat stiff and unnaturally positioned

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent adherence to the specific outfit in Image 2, including the exact scarf pattern and coat style.
• + Higher image quality and resolution with realistic fabric textures.
• + Very accurate lighting and shadow integration that matches the beach environment.

• − Significantly changed the person's facial structure and hair, making them look older and different from the source image.
• − Lost the 'Inersy' branding details on the waistband and the specific vitiligo patterns were altered.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Perfectly preserved the person's exact face, hair, and original vitiligo patterns on the skin.
• + Maintained the full composition of the source image including the wooden structure and background 1:1.

• − Completely failed to use the outfit from Image 2, instead generating a random patterned robe/suit.
• − The hands have minor anatomical distortions and the clothing fit looks slightly unnatural at the waist.

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent atmospheric lighting and photorealism
• + Very accurate rendering of the capybara's fur and expression
• + Stronger focus on the requested background element of the woman looking at her phone

• − One of the capybara's paws is missing/not visible on the wheel as requested
• − The woman's hand holding the phone looks slightly distorted

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Better adherence to the 'both front paws on the steering wheel' instruction
• + Clearer depiction of the New York City street through the window
• + Shows more of the taxi's exterior and interior for context

• − The woman in the back is not looking at a phone as requested
• − The scale of the capybara and the interior layout feels slightly unnatural

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent moody, cinematic lighting that fits the 'vintage gothic' request
• + Perfect text accuracy for all required fields
• + Highly atmospheric with subtle, spooky thorn and web textures

• − The parchment texture is very dark, making some of the background details hard to see
• − The scroll banner is a bit flat compared to the rest of the image

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Beautiful, complex composition with many thematic elements like lanterns and tombstones
• + Clear, legible gothic typography and a well-rendered scroll banner
• + Rich detail in the thorns, webs, and twisted trees

• − The lighting is bright and illustrative rather than the requested 'moody' or 'cinematic' style
• − Includes hallucinated extra text like 'Est. 1847' and 'Dress code'
• − Small visual artifacts in the sky and web sections

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Successfully added a very thick and voluminous head of hair.
• + Maintained the subject's glasses and general jacket appearance.

• − Significantly altered the facial structure, making the man look younger and like a different person.
• − The hair looks somewhat illustrative and lacks realistic fine strands at the edges.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Excellent source preservation, keeping the man's face and identity virtually identical to the original.
• + High realism in hair texture, including natural flyaways and a convincing hairline.
• + Perfectly matches the lighting and environment of the original photo.

• − The hair could be slightly thicker as per the 'full, thick head' prompt, though it is realistic.

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent typography with clean, bold text for 'JAPAN' and 'SUSHI'.
• + Accurate 45-degree isometric perspective creates a strong 3D miniature feel.
• + The lighting is soft and consistent across the diorama base.

• − The sushi toppings have a slightly overly plastic look compared to Model B.
• − The flag icon is integrated into the text line rather than separate, though still present.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + High level of surface detail on the sushi rice and toppings.
• + Intricate modeling of the garnishes and plate with a premium feel.
• + Text is correctly spelled and includes the requested flag icon.

• − Includes unrequested extra text 'Authentic Japanese Cuisine' and multiple floating artifacts in the corners.
• − The 'JAPAN' text uses a thin font that doesn't match the 'large bold' requirement as well as Model A.
• − Object placement is slightly off-center and the wooden chopsticks are cut off at the bottom.

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent caricature style with hand-drawn pencil/colored pencil texture
• + Successfully captures the subject's likeness and clothing from the source image
• + All requested elements (anchor job, dog, hockey) are integrated naturally into the scene

• − The right hand gripping the dog is small and anatomically awkward
• − The hockey stick is a bit thin and loses its shape at the top

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Creative use of a 'hockey stick microphone' and paw-print lapel pin
• + High-quality vector illustration style with clear, readable text
• + Multiple dogs included, all wearing hockey jerseys

• − Subject loses the likeness of the source image, looking more generic
• − The speech bubbles feel a bit literal and less humorous than a visual gag
• − Subject is in a suit, ignoring the specific denim shirt character of the source image

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent depiction of motion with all animals leaping and tumbling
• + Great fur rendering and soft lighting
• + Captures the 'big expressive eyes' from the prompt very well

• − The fox's front right leg looks a bit anatomically stiff
• − Butterflies are relatively simple in design

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Strong 'god ray' effects and lighting atmosphere
• + Detailed variety of wildflowers with realistic dew drops
• + Complex interactions between the animals

• − The fox appears to have two left front paws combined in a cluster
• − The kitten's facial expression is slightly distorted
• − The fox and puppy's body proportions are a bit inconsistent where they overlap

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent Ghibli-inspired art style with soft, rounded facial features.
• + Captures the requested pastel color palette and warm, nostalgic mood effectively.
• + Great textures that mimic a colored pencil or soft crayon hand-painted look.

• − The characters look slightly younger and less like the original people compared to the source.
• − Slightly less clarity in the fine patterns of the man's shirt.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Highly accurate preservation of the original subjects' faces and expressions.
• + Clean watercolor aesthetic with high-quality line work.
• + Matches the original composition and background elements very closely.

• − The style feels more like a standard digital watercolor filter than specific Ghibli-inspired art.
• − The lighting is less 'dreamy' compared to the other model.

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent adherence to the 'hair blowing in the wind' instruction.
• + Incorporates many flying leaves as requested.

• − Failed to preserve the source image's identity, completely changing the woman's facial features.
• − The dog's face and fur texture were modified unnecessarily.

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Perfectly preserves the woman's face and the dog's likeness from the source image.
• + Effectively adds dynamic hair motion and flying leaves without altering the core subjects.

• − The transition of some hair strands on the right side looks slightly unnatural/feathery.

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent typography with perfect spelling and correct accent marks
• + High contrast and clean vector style
• + Accurate inclusion of all requested elements including the cloche and banner

• − Failed the instruction for a light background, using a black background instead
• − The texture is very subtle, almost appearing as low-resolution noise

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Beautifully followed the warm brown, cream, and light background color palette
• + Sophisticated emblem style with nice illustrative details
• + Excellent subtle texture that matches the vintage aesthetic

• − Misspelled the name as 'Florion' instead of 'Florian'
• − The steam is rendered as abstract swirls rather than natural steam
• − Cloche dome looks more like a cake stand

GPT Image 1 Mini

• + Excellent typography rendering for major labels
• + Clean and playful flat-vector style with consistent line weights
• + Effective use of the requested navy and muted red palette

• − Non-sensical trajectory lines for the Translunar step
• − The composition is cropped at the bottom, cutting off the crew and footer elements
• − The Earth and Moon icons are stylistically inconsistent compared to the technical lunar module icon

Wan 2.7 Pro

• + Sophisticated and professional infographic layout with a clear hierarchy
• + Impressive attention to detail with actual mission data and dates included
• + Excellent adherence to the full request, including a complete poster layout with crew names

• − Typos in text labels, specifically 'DESCRIPT' instead of 'Descent'
• − The iconography for the lunar module is slightly fragile and lacks the 'clean' solid lines requested
• − Small text elements are slightly blurry or contain minor artifacts