FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra Black Forest Labs vs Recraft V4 Recraft AI

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent adherence to the 'cube' geometry with clean, thin edges.
• + Superior rendering of the red book with realistic textures and gold-leaf lettering.
• + Clear visibility of the plant through the glass panels.

Recraft V4

• + Very realistic wooden table texture and weathered book appearance.
• + Accurate soft window light with reflections on the sphere.

• − The glass object is a solid thick block rather than a hollow cube.
• − The sphere appears embedded in solid glass rather than 'inside' a cube.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent depiction of motion blur from passing cars.
• + High clarity and realistic lighting on the wet pavement.

• − The man appears to be posing with or leaning on the bike rather than repairing it.
• − The environment feels a bit sterile for a candid street photo.

Recraft V4

• + Stronger narrative of physical repair work through the man's posture.
• + Better adherence to the 'imperfect framing' and 'candid' street photography aesthetic.

• − The motion blur on the car is less pronounced than requested.
• − Slight anatomical distortion in the hands during the repair action.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + The image is completely black, indicating a possible policy filter or generation failure that cannot be evaluated.

• − Failed to generate any visible content.

Recraft V4

• + Excellent adherence to all prompt details including braided hair with beads and ornate engravings.
• + Highly detailed texture on leather straps and battle-worn metal surfaces.
• + Realistic lighting from torches creates a high-quality cinemantic atmosphere.

• − The 'faint' scars on the forehead appear more like skin growths or bumps than traditional scar tissue.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Features a realistic brochure-style mockup layout.
• + Strong utilization of vibrant accents and food photography.

• − Text contains gibberish and spelling errors like 'Pizzzans'.
• − Layout is somewhat cluttered with overlapping elements.

Recraft V4

• + Excellent text legibility and correct spelling throughout.
• + Perfect adherence to the grid layout and section requirements.

• − Simple white background feels slightly plain compared to a mockup.
• − Isolated food images look more like a digital asset than a finished print.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent typography with a glowing, fiery text effect that matches the prompt perfectly.
• + High-quality, appetizing burger rendering with great texture on the patties and vegetables.
• + Dramatic lighting and composition that creates a powerful 'magic' atmosphere.

• − Missed the starburst requirement for the price tag.
• − Included unnecessary hallucinated text at the bottom of the image.

Recraft V4

• + Successfully included the price in a starburst graphic.
• + Accurately captured the 'exploded view' concept with wide separation of ingredients.
• + Correctly placed all requested text elements within the composition.

• − The background is quite dark and lacks the requested 'glowing embers' and 'fiery' intensity seen in the other model.
• − The top bun looks somewhat dry and the overall color palette is less vibrant.
• − The text effect is less 'fiery and glowing' and looks more like a standard 2D graphic overlay.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + The handwriting style is very realistic with convincing chalk textures.
• + Captures a close-up, readable view of the menu board.

• − Significant text errors including gibberish words and repetitive phrases.
• − Fails to use the requested elegant cursive for the title.
• − The text layout is messy and disorganized.

Recraft V4

• + Excellent typography adherence with 100% accurate spelling for all items.
• + Beautiful composition that includes relevant chalk illustrations of the food.
• + The atmosphere of the cozy café is well-captured in the background.

• − The font, while clean, looks slightly more like a digital handwritten font than natural chalk.
• − The title is in a print style rather than the requested elegant cursive.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent anatomical rendering of the horse and astronaut gear.
• + Impressive cinematic lighting and clarity of Earth in the background.
• + Follows the general theme with high visual appeal.

• − Fails the negative constraint: the astronaut is on top of the horse, not the horse on top of the astronaut.

Recraft V4

• + High level of detail in the textures of the horse's coat and the rocky environment.
• + Strong atmosphere and sense of scale with the asteroid field.

• − Fails the negative constraint: like the other model, it depicts an astronaut riding a horse.
• − The horse's legs blending into the dust/rocks looks slightly muddled.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent texture on the capybara's fur and the jacket fabric.
• + Cinematic lighting with vibrant bokeh in the background.
• + Correct placement of front paws on the steering wheel.

• − Failed the spatial positioning of the human, who is sitting in the front passenger seat instead of the back.
• − The capybara's head scale is slightly too large for the car's interior.

Recraft V4

• + Perfectly followed the spatial prompt with the businesswoman sitting in the back seat.
• + Highly realistic lighting and rain effects on the window that enhance the 'Manhattan at night' atmosphere.
• + The capybara's clothing and pose are naturally integrated into the driver's seat.

• − The passenger's face is a bit blurry compared to the driver.
• − The steering wheel grip is slightly less defined than in the other model.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent typography rendering with crisp, legible gothic fonts
• + Well-organized composition that uses the scroll element effectively
• + Accurate inclusion of all requested elements including thorns and parchment texture

• − Included a hallucinated, garbled line of text below the banner
• − Missed a word in the main title, displaying 'Halloween Invitation' instead of 'Halloween Party Invitation'

Recraft V4

• + Successfully included the full, exact text for the main title
• + High artistic quality with atmospheric rain and complex spiderweb borders
• + Perfectly followed all event detail text requirements with no typos

• − The 'small scroll banner' is a simple white rectangle rather than an actual scroll
• − The parchment texture is less prominent compared to the background forest

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent 3D cartoon aesthetic with soft, refined textures
• + Clean and professional typography integrated into the scene
• + Strong adherence to the isometric perspective and miniature diorama feel

• − Includes minor unnecessary details like a small bug on the base
• − The typography 'JAPAN' is slightly arched rather than perfectly flat

Recraft V4

• + Text is very clean and accurately placed at the top-center
• + Realistic PBR materials on the fish itself
• + Follows the small flag icon request clearly

• − The 'ice' or 'salt' base is cluttered and lacks the 'ultra-clean' aesthetic requested
• − Misses the 3D cartoon style, opting for a photorealistic approach instead

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Exquisite lighting with soft, ethereal bokeh and god rays
• + Cohesive artistic style across all four animals
• + Clear and expressive eyes that convey the requested joyful vibe

• − Lean more toward a 3D animation style than hyper-photorealism
• − The animals are sitting relatively still, missing the active 'tumbling' requested in the prompt

Recraft V4

• + Successfully captures the dynamic action of 'chasing and tumbling' requested
• + Strikingly realistic fur textures and anatomically correct features for different species
• + Excellent use of the background with varied wildflowers and visible dew sparkles

• − The fox kit has a slightly awkward front leg position during the run
• − Butterflies appear a bit cluttered in the upper portion of the frame

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent emblem-style composition with a classic roundel and ribbon.
• + Strong color palette adherence with warm brown and cream tones.
• + Highly detailed illustration of the cloche dome and steam.

• − Misspelled the name as 'Caffé Framilian'.
• − Less minimalist than requested, leaning more into a complex emblem.

Recraft V4

• + Perfect typography that accurately renders the requested name 'Caffè Florian'.
• + Stronger adherence to the minimalist aspect of the prompt.
• + Clean vector style with excellent use of negative space.

• − Steam effect is a bit simple compared to the cloche detail.
• − Missing the banner for the 'Est. 1720' text, using a simple half-circle instead.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Strong aesthetic appeal with a professional-looking layout and color depth.
• + Good use of the navy, white, and red NASA-inspired palette.
• + Includes high-fidelity graphics for the lunar surface and stars.

• − The text is largely nonsensical gibberish or contains significant typos.
• − The sequence of steps is confusing and doesn't follow a logical numerical or spatial order.
• − Fails to correctly identify the specified icons for each step.

Recraft V4

• + Excellent text legibility and correct spelling of names and technical terms.
• + Strict adherence to the flat-vector style and iconography requirements.
• + Follows the requested sequential steps clearly and logically.

• − The composition is a bit sparse with too much empty white space.
• − The Saturn V icon lacks detail compared to the other graphics.
• − The 'Translunar' icon is overly simplistic and doesn't explicitly show an arc between points.