FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra Black Forest Labs vs Qwen Image Max Alibaba

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + The glass transparency is incredibly realistic with subtle dust and reflections.
• + Excellent adherence to the 'soft window light from the left' instruction, reflected in the cube and on the table.
• + Higher factual detail in the book texture and the plant visibility through the glass.

• − The blue sphere is levitating without a clear physical support, though this could be interpreted as artistic.

Qwen Image Max

• + Strong color saturation on the blue sphere which makes it pop.
• + Good composition and clear following of the layout requirements.

• − The glass cube walls have inconsistent thickness and some strange internal reflections.
• − The plant pot is merged oddly with the background and the glass reflections are slightly muddy.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• − The image failed to load or is a solid black block.

Qwen Image Max

• + Excellent adherence to all prompt details including braided hair with beads, scars, and ornate engraving.
• + Exceptional texture rendering on the leather straps and weathered skin.
• + Beautiful lighting with glowing bokeh sparks and realistic torchlight reflections.

• − The bokeh sparks appear slightly disconnected from any specific light source in the foreground.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent text legibility and clean graphic design.
• + High-quality, photorealistic food textures throughout.
• + Good implementation of the 'exploded' concept with vertical suspension.

• − Missed the 'starburst' requirement for the price tag.
• − Includes nonsensical AI-generated filler text at the bottom corners.
• − The burger layers appear somewhat repetitive rather than a single 'exploded' burger.

Qwen Image Max

• + Accurately included the starburst for the '€6.99' text.
• + Strong sense of motion and dynamic energy with embers and sparks.
• + The fiery font for the title better matches the requested aesthetic.

• − The burger is not fully 'exploded'; the top bun and patty are still touching.
• − The logo and text have some slight aliasing/jitter on the edges.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Features a more modern and sleek photographic style
• + The capybara's texture and clothing are well-rendered
• + Atmospheric bokeh in the background creates a strong cinematic feel

• − The passenger is sitting in the front seat instead of the back seat as requested
• − The woman is looking at her phone but her position and the steering wheel overlap incorrectly
• − The car layout is ambiguous and doesn't clearly show a back seat or partition

Qwen Image Max

• + Accurately places the passenger in the back seat as per the prompt
• + Captures the bored, normal expression of the businesswoman very well
• + Better adherence to the 'two front paws on the steering wheel' instruction with realistic grip

• − The capybara's paws look more like primate hands, which is anatomically incorrect
• − The interior of the taxi appears quite aged and worn, which may not be the intended aesthetic
• − Lighting on the capybara's face is a bit flat compared to the city light spill in Model A

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent typography rendering for the main title and address.
• + Very intricate scroll and thorny border detail.
• + Clear and polished cinematic lighting.

• − Included a significant text hallucination below the scroll ('noickt or').
• − Missing the word 'Party' in the primary title text.

Qwen Image Max

• + Followed all text instructions perfectly, including 'Party' in the title.
• + Better integration of the jack-o-lantern within the spooky landscape.
• + Effective use of the requested moody night sky and crescent moon.

• − The thorn border is a bit repetitive compared to the organic feel of model A.
• − The scroll banner text is slightly uneven in its curve.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent layout that uses the square format effectively.
• + Sophisticated soft lighting and 3D diorama aesthetic.
• + Clean, integrated typography that follows the curvature of the design.

• − The text 'JAPAN' is slightly transparent and less bold than requested.
• − Includes some odd miniature elements like a small bug on the base.

Qwen Image Max

• + Text is very bold, clear, and follows the hierarchy requested.
• + Realistic material textures on the salmon and tamago sushi.
• + Perfectly centered and simple composition.

• − The glass base has some slight perspective distortion on the left edge.
• − The shadows under the text are a bit heavy compared to the soft lighting of the scene.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Captures the 'big expressive eyes' and soft lighting requested in the prompt perfectly.
• + Consistent, high-quality fur rendering across all animals.
• + Excellent color harmony and beautiful bokeh effects.

• − The animals are sitting still rather than 'playfully chasing and tumbling'.
• − The animals look more like stylized plush toys than 'hyper-photorealistic' creatures.

Qwen Image Max

• + Successfully depicts the 'tumbling' and 'chasing' action requested in the prompt.
• + Features more realistic lighting with clear god rays and dew-like sparkles.
• + Better variety in butterfly colors and environment textures.

• − Missing the baby bunny requested in the prompt.
• − Anatomical issues with the animals, notably the puppy on the bottom having an oddly placed and shaped paw.
• − The kitten's stripes are a bit harsh/unnatural.

FLUX1.1 [pro] Ultra

• + Excellent vector emblem layout with clean circular composition.
• + Professional typography and high visual crispness.
• + Accurate color palette according to the prompt.

• − Misspelled the primary brand name as 'Caffè Framlian'.
• − Minimalist style is slightly lost in the busy circular details.

Qwen Image Max

• + Perfect adherence to the brand name 'Caffè Florian'.
• + Charming retro steam illustration.
• + Consistent vintage texture on the background.

• − The 'Est. 1720' text is placed on a banner but is not an emblem style.
• − The parchment background is a bit clichéd compared to a clean vector style.