FLUX.2 [dev] Black Forest Labs vs Wan 2.7 Alibaba

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent photographic lighting and depth of field.
• + Perfect adherence to spatial instructions with the sphere inside the cube.
• + High realism in textures, particularly the wood grain and glass reflections.

• − The sphere appears slightly glossier than expected, bordering on a marble texture.

Wan 2.7

• + Realistic vintage look for the red book with visible binding details.
• + Accomplishes all prompt requirements including lighting direction.
• + Natural-looking houseplant with believable leaf structures.

• − Perspective and reflection errors; there is a phantom blue sphere reflection/artifact on the left side of the glass.
• − The glass cube has internal vertical seams that make it look more like a case than a solid object.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Successfully preserved the man's specific clothing and hairstyle
• + Maintained the interior details and leather of the car
• + Excellent integration of the man into the driver's seat with realistic lighting

• − The exterior of the car is cropped out of the frame
• − The man's facial features changed slightly compared to the source

Wan 2.7

• + Accurately captured the full vista of the California coastline
• + Preserved the full exterior of the car correctly
• + Good sense of motion on the road

• − Completely failed to use the specific man from the source image
• − The person in the car is a generic, low-detail figure
• − Lost the likeness and outfit requested in the image editing prompt

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent adherence to the motion blur requirement for passing cars.
• + Very realistic skin texture and age-appropriate details on the hands and face.
• + Superior lighting and reflections on the wet jacket and pavement.

• − The bicycle geometry is slightly confusing with excess frame bars and overlapping parts.
• − The 'imperfect framing' is very subtle, remaining fairly centered.

Wan 2.7

• + Strong candid 'street photo' composition with a wide-angle feel.
• + Captures the wet pavement reflections and rainy atmosphere very well.
• + Great clothing texture showing dampness and wear.

• − Completely missed the 'motion blur from passing cars' instruction; the cars are crisp.
• − Hand-to-handlebar interaction is slightly muddy and less detailed than Image A.
• − The skin texture is a bit smoother and less 'natural' than Model A.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent depiction of colorful beads in the braids
• + Beautiful warm torchlight reflection and glowing bokeh sparks
• + High quality engraving details on the chest plate

• − The scars look a bit like fresh red stage makeup rather than weathered battle scars
• − The torch in the corner is a bit blurry and takes up significant frame space

Wan 2.7

• + Exceptional skin texture with realistic pores and believable battle-worn scars
• + Highly detailed braided hair and leather-like texture on the straps
• + Strong sense of 'battle-worn' through the dented and scratched armor

• − The beads are very uniform and simple compared to Model A
• − The torchlight is slightly less warm on the skin tones

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent grid layout with clear horizontal and vertical alignment.
• + Strong, bold typography used for headings that is easy to read.
• + Accurate categorization of appetizers, pizza, and mains.

• − The text content within the menu items is mostly gibberish.
• − The food photos lack descriptive labels making it feel like a template shell.

Wan 2.7

• + Features actual legible text and coherent food labels.
• + High visual appeal with a photorealistic presentation including props around the menu.
• + Consistent iconography and a clean, modern aesthetic with brand elements like a QR code.

• − The 'sides' and 'drinks' section photos include a burger and cake, which feels inconsistent with the header navigation.
• − Small text becomes slightly blurry upon close inspection.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent photorealistic texture on the meat patty and bun
• + Clean and readable text with a consistent fiery glow effect
• + Perfect vertical alignment of the exploded burger components

• − The 'exploded' effect is quite subtle compared to model B
• − The sauce droplets look slightly artificial

Wan 2.7

• + Very dynamic composition with a strong sense of motion and 'exploded' elements
• + Detailed texture on the lettuce and grilled patty
• + Creative fiery typography for the main title

• − Sesame seeds are floating individually in space rather than being on the bun
• − The 'starburst' for the price looks more like a sun or gear than a traditional graphic burst

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent chalk texture throughout the board.
• + Strong adherence to the requested 'handwritten' style with visible smudges and imperfections.
• + Successfully completed the truncated third item correctly based on context.

• − The spacing on the second item 'Grilled Octopus' is a bit cluttered.
• − The handwriting style is slightly messy, though fits the 'chalkboard' aesthetic.

Wan 2.7

• + Very clean and legible text alignment.
• + Good composition with decorative divider lines.
• + Successfully completed the third item as 'Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies'.

• − The text looks more like a digital font than actual hand-drawn chalk.
• − Fails the prompt's requirement for 'realistic chalk handwriting' and 'no digital fonts'.
• − The 'chalk' texture on the letters is too uniform and lacks natural variation.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Successfully integrated character elements like the sunglasses, scarf, and black sweater.
• + Captured the likeness of the man from Image 2.

• − Horrific anatomical failure with a second head and distorted limbs.
• − Failed to match the pose correctly, resulting in a surreal and incoherent composition.

Wan 2.7

• + Maintained perfect anatomical coherence and image quality.
• + Preserved the environment and lighting of the source pose image perfectly.

• − Completely failed the character swap instruction.
• − Made no visible changes to the person from Image 1.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent cinematic lighting and atmosphere
• + Realistic textures on both the horse's coat and the spacesuit
• + Dynamic and natural horse pose

• − Failed the specific spatial instruction for the horse to be on top of the astronaut

Wan 2.7

• + Clear and sharp focus throughout the image
• + Consistent anatomy for the horse and astronaut
• + Well-defined background elements like galaxies and planets

• − Failed the specific spatial instruction for the horse to be on top of the astronaut
• − Composition feels slightly flat compared to Model A

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Successfully transferred the specific blue coat and plaid scarf from Image 2.
• + Maintained the sand patches on the person's face.
• + Good lighting integration on the fabric.

• − Failed to preserve the source person's face, blending it heavily with the face from Image 2.
• − Ignored the requirement to keep the background completely unchanged, adding a beach that wasn't there in the same way.

Wan 2.7

• + Excellent preservation of the source person's identity, vitiligo patterns, and facial structure.
• + Maintained the exact background and wood structure from Image 1.
• + High-quality rendering of fabric and jewelry detail.

• − Failed to use the 'exact outfit' from Image 2, instead generating a generic 'elaborate' gold-trimmed coat and vest.
• − Distorted the hand details slightly.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent fur texture and lighting on the capybara.
• + Accurately places the passenger in the back seat as requested.
• + The bokeh in the background maintains a high degree of photorealism.

Wan 2.7

• + Sharp details on the car exterior and taxi sign.
• + Good depiction of the capybara's paws on the steering wheel.

• − The passenger is incorrectly sitting in the front passenger seat.
• − The capybara's fur has a slightly stylized, comb-like appearance rather than being photorealistic.
• − Anatomical issues with the capybara's paws looking more like human-monkey hybrids.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent typography with perfect spelling and alignment.
• + High-contrast cinematic lighting that creates a moody, spooky atmosphere.
• + Central Jack-o-lantern is well-integrated with the background elements.

• − The parchment effect is limited to the outer edges rather than the whole background.
• − The 'webs and thorns' border is a bit dark and blends into the background shadow.

Wan 2.7

• + Successfully captures a 'vintage poster' aesthetic with detailed illustrations.
• + Includes all requested text elements accurately along with creative additions.
• + Complex and symmetrical composition with great use of the parchment texture.

• − The character of the central jack-o-lantern is slightly more cartoonish than 'cinematic'.
• − The image feels a bit crowded with many small secondary elements like skulls and books.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent preservation of the original image's background, clothing, and facial features.
• + Realistic hair texture and complex lighting integration.

• − The choice of an oversized afro style feels less 'natural' as an extension of the subject's existing beard and aesthetic.
• − The hairline integration at the forehead lacks some fine transition detail.

Wan 2.7

• + Provides a very natural and believable hairstyle that fits the subject's age and existing beard perfectly.
• + Flawless preservation of the original image's environment and lighting.
• + The hairline is extremely realistic and well-integrated.

• − There are minor texture artifacts where the hair meets the top edge of the glasses frame.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent adherence to the typographic layout requested.
• + High-quality PBR material rendering on the sushi fish and rice.
• + Cleaner, more minimalist diorama base that feels more premium.

• − The white plate is slightly off-center on the diorama base.
• − The text 'SUSHI' is relatively plain compared to the bold 'JAPAN'.

Wan 2.7

• + Beautiful color palette and vibrant textures on the ingredients.
• + Great variety of sushi items included in the miniature scene.
• + The diorama base has a nice rounded architectural feel.

• − Failed to follow text placement instructions, putting text in a single block with the flag to the right.
• − Included many more elements (chopsticks, sauce, napkins) than the 'minimal' request.
• − The shrimp tail has a slight anatomical oddity with multiple segment points.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Expertly captures the caricature art style with exaggerated proportions.
• + Integrated the TV anchor profession seamlessly into a hockey rink setting.
• + Preserved the subject's likeness effectively within the stylized art form.

• − The text on the anchor desk is garbled and unreadable.
• − The inclusion of a second human caricature was not requested and feels a bit cluttered.

Wan 2.7

• + Maintained the original 'selfie' composition from the source image.
• + Humorous incorporation of hockey themes, such as the dog in the goalie mask and the tiny rink.
• + Clear, readable text in the speech bubbles.

• − The facial caricature is a bit generic and loses some of the subject's specific likeness compared to the source.
• − The transition between the subject and the TV background is slightly messy.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent photorealism with soft, naturalistic lighting
• + High detail in the fur texture and dew droplets
• + Features all requested animals with clear, expressive eyes

• − Added an extra bunny that wasn't explicitly requested
• − The animals are sitting still rather than 'playfully chasing' or 'tumbling'

Wan 2.7

• + Better captures the action of 'playfully chasing' and 'tumbling'
• + Strong 'god rays' lighting effect as requested
• + All four specific animals are present and uniquely identifiable

• − The fox looks slightly more like an adult than a kit
• − Anatomically awkward kitten paws and tail positioning
• − The lighting feels slightly more artificial and over-saturated than Image A

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent adherence to the 'Ghibli' style with clean linework and soft, flat coloring.
• + Successfully transforms the background into a dreamy, meadow-like setting requested in the prompt.
• + Perfectly captures the 'warm, nostalgic' lighting and pastel color palette.

• − Changes the background entirely, losing the original urban street context.

Wan 2.7

• + Successfully preserves the original composition, including the background buildings and passersby.
• + The watercolor texture aligns well with the 'hand-painted' requirement.
• + Retains the recognizable facial features of the people in the original meme.

• − Art style feels more like a standard Western watercolor illustration than Studio Ghibli.
• − The lighting lacks the 'dreamy' quality requested in the prompt.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent depiction of wind-blown hair with high energy
• + Perfect preservation of the original person and dog's identity
• + Adds a significant amount of leaves to enhance the motion effect

• − The hair takes on a slightly unnatural, fan-like spread
• − Some leaves overlap the subjects in a slightly cluttered way

Wan 2.7

• + More natural and subtle hair movement that matches a real breeze
• + Leaves have motion blur which enhances the 'dynamic' feel
• + Maintains the lighting and colors of the source image perfectly

• − Fewer leaves added compared to Model A, feeling slightly less 'energetic'
• − The motion effect on the hair is less dramatic than requested

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent typography with perfect spelling of 'Caffè Florian'.
• + Beautifully minimalist vector style that adheres perfectly to the 'emblem' request.
• + Superior handling of the banner and subtle paper texture.

• − The steam is very simple, though this fits the minimalist style.

Wan 2.7

• + Ornate and attractive circular frame design.
• + Clean, readable text for the 'Est. 1720' portion.
• + Good interpretation of the 'warm brown' color palette.

• − Failed spelling of the primary subject, rendering the name as 'Florion' instead of 'Florian'.
• − Lack of 'banner' for the establishment date as requested; it uses a badge instead.
• − Less 'minimalist' than requested, bordering on cluttered.

FLUX.2 [dev]

• + Excellent vector art style with high-quality gradients and shading
• + Accurate depiction of the Lunar Module and Saturn V components
• + High clarity in individual icons

• − Poor layout logic with random grid placement
• − Garbled text in several labels
• − Failed to follow the numbered step sequence requested

Wan 2.7

• + Perfect logical layout following the requested step-by-step sequence
• + Excellent textual accuracy and supporting data integration
• + Strong adherence to the 'infographic' format with a clear flow

• − Icon design is more simplistic compared to Model A
• − One minor typo ('Descript' instead of 'Descent')
• − Visual elements are slightly more cramped