Nano Banana Pro vs P-Image Edit

Head-to-head across 1 challenge

Nano Banana Pro

100.0%

win rate

Ties

0.0%

P-Image Edit

0.0%

win rate

100.0% 0.0% ties 0.0%

Challenge Results

Outfit Transfer Challenge

Editing

Edit instruction

“Use Image 1 as the base person. Dress them in the exact elaborate outfit from Image 2 (including all layers, accessories, jewelry, and shoes). Carefully adapt the clothing to the body shape and pose in Image 1 while maintaining realistic fabric behavior, correct proportions, and perfect lighting/shadow matching. Keep the person’s exact face, hair, and background completely unchanged.”

Source

Nano Banana Pro

P-Image Edit

100% wins 0% ties 0% wins

AI Judge Analysis

Nano Banana Pro

+ Excellent preservation of the person's identity and facial details.
+ Highly realistic fabric texture and lighting that matches the environmental scene.
+ Accurate replication of the coat and scarf patterns from Image 2.

− The crop was changed to a closer shot, losing the lower legs/shoes.
− Missed some specific accessories like the ring from Image 2.

P-Image Edit

+ Successfully applied the full outfit including legs and shoes.
+ Maintained the full-body composition of the scene.

− Significantly altered the facial features and skin patterns of the original person.
− The lighting on the clothing is oversaturated and flat compared to the original scene.
− Introduced an unnecessary gold chain that was not in Image 2.

Verdict: Nano Banana Pro followed the instructions much more effectively by perfectly preserving the face and hair of the subject from Image 1, even though it cropped the image. P-Image Edit failed on the core requirement of keeping the face unchanged, resulting in a different person, and the lighting on the clothes feels disconnected from the beach background. Nano Banana Pro's output feels like a professional composite, whereas P-Image Edit looks like a low-quality face-swap.